Member

At the moment, as we have heard, the cases go on and on. My noble friend Lord Murray’s amendment, proposing the NAAB, and my noble friend Lord Gower’s, proposing scientific methods, both aim to deal with a difficult problem. We have to decide on as near a factual way as possible, for the very reasons that have been stated—the danger we pose by putting people who are over 18 into a category with younger people in all the circumstances that the local authority oversees, and the cost to the taxpayer of protracted proceedings and judicial review. It is unsatisfactory and undermines confidence in our judicial system, the courts and, indeed, the way we organise our democracy. There will never be a perfect solution, but we must work towards whichever amendment is judged to be better for securing the best available evidence on age.