Lord Offord of Garvel (Con)

My Lords, I thank all noble Lords who have contributed to this very important debate. I pay tribute to the noble Lord, Lord Rees of Easton, for a very elegant maiden speech. Of course, the whole point of debate is to challenge consensus, and I am delighted that I have been able to do that today. Was it not Benjamin Franklin who said that when everyone is thinking the same thing, no one is thinking? Allow me to sum up as follows. Our energy is the most expensive in the developed world. This is self-inflicted and it is not fair on ordinary working people, who pay the price. It is grotesque and unfair to see billions of pounds in curtailment subsidies going to owners of what are quite often foreign-owned wind farms, just because the wind blows too hard at the wrong time. Net zero is a laudable aim, but the purpose of this debate is to ask how we reassess it, not remove it, because we are in danger that the public will begin to see this as the biggest transfer of money from the poor to the rich since feudal times. Make no mistake: these green levies and taxes on working people are viewed as attacks on working people and a drag anchor on our industry. We must not allow that to happen or to be the perception. Therefore, my argument is simply that 2025 is 25 years away from net zero 2050, so this is a good time to reassess the plan in the light of reality and to re-evaluate our energy strategy, with the simple objective that we must make it affordable and secure. We are living in different times from when this was moved in 2019. We need to make our energy affordable and secure. We need to reindustrialise our great nation. We need to get our proud people back to work. We need to be strong and independent in an uncertain world. We may well need to rebuild our military capability to keep us strong and protect our citizens, but above all, we need to give comfort, security and prosperity to all the inhabitants of these islands. Therefore, it is high time that this House takes note of the affordability of net zero 2050. I commend this Motion to your Lordships’ House.