Baroness Barran (Con)

My Lords, I rise to speak to Amendment 30 in my name and that of the noble Lord, Lord Storey; I also support Amendment 31 in the names of my noble friends Lord Black of Brentwood and Lord Lexden, which seeks to include a review on the effect that this Bill will have across the education sector. I think it is safe to say that both the noble Lord, Lord Storey, and I do not believe that the long-standing tradition that education should be free from taxation should be broken. Clearly, the Government do not agree with us, and we have seen this with the egregious introduction of VAT on independent school fees and now with the proposed change in this Bill to the exemption from business rates relief for independent schools with charitable status, not to mention the impact of the proposed employer national insurance contribution increases. As the Minister knows, the majority of independent schools are small and run on tight margins. As he will remember from my speech in Committee, I believe it is a poor precedent for the Government to set to create a two-tier charity system and there has been no answer from the Government about this principle that all charities should be treated equally. This feels like a rather political move and charities, of all organisations, should be free from such moves. I assume that the noble Lord is going to argue that there has been no sign that pupil numbers are dropping significantly following the introduction of VAT in January and that this Bill will similarly have a limited impact. But I say to the Minister that, first, the point that the principle that education should never be taxed still stands and, secondly, I do not think anyone really expected the impact on independent schools from the imposition of VAT would happen so quickly. I am sure the noble Lord has received letters from parents, just as I have. They will go to great lengths to avoid disrupting their children’s education and I would be surprised if we see much change before the start of the new school year, and then from a reduced uptake in year 7. Indeed, the latest data from the Independent Schools Council shows a drop of 4.6% in applicants in year 7 and 3.9% in reception—and that was before the imposition of VAT. I look forward to hearing the insights from other noble Lords and to hearing the Minister’s response, but at this point I am minded to test the opinion of the House.