Baroness Brady (Con)

I do not say that they do or do not. I am saying that, if they were not there, you would have to invent them. If a club is promoted from the Championship to the Premier League and cannot invest in its team to stay in that league, it is automatically almost certain to be relegated. If an established club, such as those mentioned earlier, is relegated, without the parachute payment it will be in financial trouble. Some 50% of all administrations come as a result of relegation; that is why parachute payments are fundamentally important. They are designed to manage the financial shock of relegation, where clubs could lose significant revenues, almost overnight, while their costs remain fixed. For a recently promoted Premier League club, squad costs alone average £115 million a year, with most player contracts running for three to five years. Relegation means that clubs face an average shortfall of £165 million over three years, even with parachute payments included in that equation. It is important to recognise, therefore, that they do not help clubs avoid a painful transition but soften the blow to a degree. Without them, the financial impact would escalate from being very painful to being catastrophic.