Member

341: After Clause 99, insert the following new Clause— “Duration and review(1) This Act expires at the end of the period of five years beginning with the day on which section 5 comes into force (“the initial period”), subject to the provisions of this section and section (Renewal and dissolution provisions).(2) The Secretary of State must establish an independent review panel (“the Panel”) no later than 15 months before the end of the initial period.(3) The Panel must—(a) carry out a review of—(i) the effectiveness of this Act, (ii) whether the IFR has remained within its statutory purposes, and(iii) whether the objectives of the Act could be achieved through less interventionist means,(b) prepare a report of the review, and(c) lay a copy of the report before Parliament, no later than 12 months before the end of the initial period.(4) The Panel must consist of—(a) at least one person with expertise in competition law,(b) at least one person with expertise in regulatory policy,(c) at least one person with expertise in football administration, and(d) at least one person with expertise in business regulation.(5) Where there is a change in the person holding the office of Secretary of State after the establishment of the Panel but before the report is laid before Parliament—(a) the new Secretary of State may by written notice dissolve the existing Panel,(b) where the Panel is dissolved under paragraph (a), the new Secretary of State must—(i) establish a new Panel within 28 days,(ii) ensure the new Panel meets the requirements of subsection (4), and(iii) extend the period for the laying of the report by up to three months if necessary to allow the new Panel to complete its work,(c) the new Panel may—(i) consider any work undertaken by the previous Panel,(ii) adopt any findings of the previous Panel that it considers appropriate, or(iii) conduct an entirely new review.(6) The new Secretary of State may only exercise the power under subsection (5) once in relation to the review required by subsection (3).(7) The report under subsection (3) must include—(a) an assessment of whether the IFR has—(i) achieved its objectives under section 6,(ii) remained within the scope of its original purposes as set out in section 1,(iii) avoided expanding its regulatory reach beyond its core functions,(iv) maintained proportionate intervention in the football industry,(b) an assessment of—(i) the regulatory burden imposed by the Act,(ii) the costs of compliance for regulated entities,(iii) whether the objectives could be achieved through less intrusive means,(c) an analysis of any instance where the IFR has—(i) exceeded its statutory powers,(ii) created additional regulatory requirements beyond those explicitly authorised by the Act,(iii) expanded its interpretation of its objectives beyond their original scope,(d) a specific assessment of whether market conditions still justify statutory regulation, and(e) a recommendation as to whether the Act should be—(i) allowed to expire,(ii) renewed for a further period with specific restrictions, or(iii) renewed without modification.”