Lord Cryer (Lab)

My Lords, Amendment 85F in the name of the noble Lord, Lord Murray, and Amendments 85G and 85H in the name of the noble Lord, Lord Fuller, would require the Secretary of State to give GBE directions to regularly report on the impact of its investments on electricity generation from solar, renewable and wind sources in the UK. We have already set out in this debate the need to avoid placing excessive reporting burdens on GBE. Nevertheless, the concerns raised remain pertinent. It is important for GBE to maintain its operational independence and to ensure its long-term success, which these amendments would hinder. Further, the intended use of Clause 6, as has been repeated again and again, is to give directions for urgent situations only. These amendments would broaden it unnecessarily. On renewables specifically, I assure your Lordships that GBE will focus on driving clean energy deployment. This will inevitably include a range of renewable resources, including solar and wind. GBE will be an operationally independent company and the exact mix of technologies it chooses to invest in will be determined in due course. On accountability, which the noble Lord, Lord Murray, and others raised, let us bear in mind that the Secretary of State can be—and is—called before the energy Select Committee at any time. As far as the chief accounting officer is concerned, he or she can be called before the Public Accounts Committee, which, looking at the PAC’s track record, I would have thought is highly likely to take place. As we are all aware, the Secretary of State is also accountable to the House of Commons every few weeks. That includes—and this is pertinent—Topical Questions, which, in a fairly recent change to Question Time in the other place, are included in every Question Time, which means that things that have only just happened that do not have a relevant Question on the Order Paper can be raised by MPs of any party. Of course, annual reports will have to be submitted to Companies House in the usual way. That is set out in statute. On that basis, I urge noble Lords not to press their amendments.