Lord Falconer of Thoroton (Lab)

Thirdly, I join with everybody in the Committee in deprecating vicious attacks on the noble Lord, Lord Sandhurst, and the noble Baroness, Lady Finlay. Any one of us who have been involved in this get vicious attacks outside. I agree with the noble Baroness, Lady Fox, when she says there is a slightly testy atmosphere from time to time in here. The best that we can do to try and fight off those attacks is to be as good-natured, funny and warm as we normally are. I am looking forward to the noble Lord, Lord Deben, being warm and funny again. Fourthly, my Amendment 131A, which the noble Lord, Lord Harper, mentioned, would add that the Prime Minister is to consult the Welsh Ministers before making the appointment. I hope that nobody objects to that; it is what the Welsh Senedd effectively agreed by passing the LCM. When we come to that amendment, I will move it, as I detect no objections. Finally, I am afraid I will not provide the noble Lord, Lord Moore of Etchingham, with any assistance in relation to the way he conducts himself in the Committee. He always conducts himself, if I may say so, with impeccable manners and courtesy. It is for each one of us to determine what is appropriate and what is not. I will deal with the amendments quite quickly. They are all to deal with the voluntary assisted dying commissioner provided for in Clause 4. The voluntary assisted dying commissioner will be appointed by the Prime Minister. As my noble friend Lady Levitt, the Minister, has indicated, as long as that stays in, then it will be subject to an open appointment procedure involving an assessment panel. The idea of the noble Lord, Lord Beith, is perfectly commendable: should a Select Committee look at the appointment? The way that would work in practice is that it would be for the Cabinet Office and the individual Select Committee to agree whether the appointment should be subject to a Select Committee procedure. I would be in favour of it. I do not think it is appropriate to put it into the Bill, but I can see real merit in it. Iwould not only have no objection to it, but I think it is a good idea.