Lord Markham (Con)

I thank noble Lords for their contribution to this debate, and again I thank the Minister for her response. I noticed that she went into the detail of the backstop mechanism but I did not hear in that the more fundamental point about why she believes that the regulator needs to be bestowed these unparalleled powers to redistribute income where there are no examples of market failure. In fact, there are the examples of the very healthy Premier League and Championship, which are respectively the first and sixth richest leagues in the world—and all the result, as my noble friends pointed out, of a voluntary agreement and distribution between them all. However, the whole prospect of the backstop happening is creating the reverse. As I understand it, those negotiations have stopped. Of course, it is entirely rational from the EFL’s point of view to stop them, because why reach an agreement when suddenly you are going to have more negotiating leverage because you have a regulator which will come in? So, again, it is perfectly rational behaviour on the part of the EFL to reach the best agreement it can with the Premier League but then instead of finally agreeing with it, appeal to the regulator in case it can get more because it has already banked what it has got from the Premier League and there is only an upside to doing that. So I am afraid that I believe this whole mechanism will actually create more friction and more disputes, rather than less, and will mean that it is less likely to reach a voluntary agreement. In addition, as I mentioned before, I still have not heard why we feel that the regulator needs these powers in the first place when we have a successful situation in place already. As a result of that, I believe that these powers will endanger the whole size of the cake that is available for distribution. It will endanger the success and the revenue gained from that, which will result in a loss to everyone. We will definitely return to this on Report but at this stage I beg leave to withdraw.