Member

Although I understand the intention behind Amendment 10—transparency in public health policy is, of course, a legitimate aim and I would like to see far more of it—I am afraid I am not drawn to the idea of imposing frequent and prescriptive reporting obligations on tobacco manufacturers and importers in the way it proposes. Obligations of this kind could be imposed on industry where there is a clear public health gain. I am prepared to consider this further, but I am afraid I am not yet convinced that the amendment passes that test. Having said that, I look forward to the Minister’s responses to other noble Lords.