Lord Deben (Con)

My Lords, I am hoping that I am going to help the noble and learned Lord, Lord Falconer, and I am sure he will be pleased with that help. We have been discussing some fundamental issues of interest to the people who are going to have to carry this Bill through. Therefore, I recommend three very simple things to the noble and learned Lord. First, the sooner we know what the noble and learned Lord’s amendments are going to be, the very much better it will be. It would allow some of us to help—certainly not me, but the experts—to make sure they are adequate. Secondly, I support the noble and learned Baroness, Lady Butler-Sloss, in her demand that we should know as much as possible in advance. Thirdly—and the gravamen of my points—if you talk to people outside, many of them have no idea about the details of the Bill and have a general view either in favour or against it. However, when you talk to people who have some real understanding of the Bill, the issues which concern them most are those where they feel there is not adequate clarity, especially for the medics and others who are going to be involved. This debate has been different, if I may say to the noble and learned Lord, from previous debates on this area. It has concentrated on the lack of clarity around what we really mean by competence. We have made the distinction between the competence that is satisfactory to make important but immediate decisions that can be reversed and the competence necessary to make fundamental decisions, where a person needs a longer-term ability. It therefore seems to me that it would be advantageous to the noble and learned Lord’s whole cause if he could take this very seriously. If he can find a proper answer, which satisfies the sensible things that have been said, it will go very much further—this is a rather delicate sentence, which I hope the noble and learned Lord will not take amiss—to repair the impression that every amendment is shoved off. These are not amendments to treat with anything but the very greatest of care.