Baroness Noakes (Con)

My Lords, the noble Baroness, Lady Kramer, was kind enough to refer to the committee I chair. I will offer a few comments on this area. First, in line with what I said on the previous group of amendments, I do not believe that this is a regulatory principle in any real sense. It is certainly not one directed just at the PRA and the FCA; for example, the system-wide exploratory scenario, which the noble Baroness referred to, is being undertaken by the financial stability arm of the Bank. She referred to Sarah Breeden—that is her area, and she is not in the PRA or the FCA. The noble Baroness, Lady Bennett of Manor Castle, read out some headlines from the Financial Times. She is right that there is a lot of noise around private credit. It is all based in the United States at the moment. It is often said that what starts in America comes to the UK, but there are a lot of differences between what has happened in the US, including what has gone seriously wrong, and what has happened here. It is encouraging that the Bank of England has taken the initiative to carry out the system-wide exploratory stress scenario—it is the only central bank in the world to do so. There was criticism that this was voluntary, and that is because the players in the private credit market are not regulated organisations and so they have no obligation under existing law to provide information. However, it is my understanding that the degree of involvement of the organisations taking part that are not directly regulated by the PRA or the FCA—or are not involved in the activities we are discussing—has been satisfactory. One thing I considered tabling for this Committee was the question of whether the Bank of England has sufficient powers to get the information from the non-regulated sector if it needed to do so. I would be grateful if the Minister could reflect on that question. All the time the information is being adequately obtained voluntarily, I do not see any need to legislate for it; I am just not aware of whether there is a backstop power, and I ran out of brain power for drafting an amendment to find out about that. I am grateful to the noble Baroness for giving me a cue to raise this issue. A lot of issues arise in relation to the impact of private credit on the existing regulated organisations—banks and insurance companies—but it is also fair to say that, although there is not complete transparency on what the second-order impact would be if there was a stress in this situation, there is a lot of awareness and supervisory engagement with the key players, as was explained to us during the conduct of the inquiry that my committee undertook. The committee did not find such a scary situation as has been portrayed by other Members of the Committee this afternoon.