Lord Clement-Jones (LD)

My Lords, Amendment 148A stands in my name on the Marshalled List. This amendment would address a profound, structural and deeply disturbing gap in the judicial oversight and democratic accountability of the Bill. It represents a direct implementation of the authoritative recommendation of the Select Committee on the Constitution, in its third report of this Session. Under Clause 50, the Secretary of State, acting as the direct enforcement authority for national security directions, is empowered to issue a unilateral confirmation decision that potentially imposes hugely significant financial penalties on non-compliant organisations. Under Clause 49, these penalties can reach a peak of up to £17 million or 10% of global turnover for commercial undertakings. Even for non-undertakings—such as our cash-strapped NHS trusts, local government authorities, or educational bodies—the penalty can be a crushing £17 million, with daily ongoing fines of up to £100,000 per day. Yet, under the Bill as currently drafted, the Government expect us to accept that the only avenue of legal recourse for an affected organisation to challenge these business-destroying fines is judicial review in the High Court.