Simon Hoare

The hon. Lady is making a principled argument that the House must listen to and respect, but she has spoken about choice and dignity, and the one thing I have never understood about this Bill is the i

Against a backdrop of realism—things just go wrong, no matter how much money is invested in them, or how up to date they are—does it not seem slightly ludicrous that NATS has put all its eggs in one b

I agree. There is a common theme coming through, which is the age, the vulnerability, the “anything for the quiet life,” the “We’re not empowered to ask questions,” and maybe not being digitally alert

The hon. Gentleman has been frightfully patient. I will give way to him.

That is a good suggestion. Anything has to be better than the status quo, which is neither defensible nor indeed desirable.

I will not, if the hon. Gentleman will forgive me, because we want to hear from the Minister. I am told that Cognatum and its subsidiaries claim small companies exemptions, meaning that there are no i