Contribution
My Lords, it is a pleasure to have the opportunity to take part in this debate. I warmly support the regret amendment tabled by my noble friend on the Front Bench, the noble Lord, Lord Sharpe of Epsom.
In a period of great difficulty and challenge for small businesses—a situation of increasing inflation, tax rises, supply chain blockages, consumer confidence dropping, national insurance payments going up, youth and graduate unemployment, low growth, and poor productivity in the public sector—one would expect that this Government would give businesses a break. In July, 90% of businesses surveyed by the Federation of Small Businesses were worried about this measure, and only 18% expected business to grow.
People criticise the Labour Party for not having much knowledge or experience of business and investment, but you cannot say the same of the trade unions. Since 2010, they have invested £142 million in the Labour Party through donations. They have bought and paid for this legislation in a way that is quite outrageous, especially when we are lectured on a regular basis by the Labour Party on ethics and the appropriateness of corporate donations. We must not forget that it was not just the trade unions: just before the 2024 general election, the Labour Party received £4 million from the Quadrature Capital hedge fund.
This is problematic and an obvious example of the idiom of gilding the lily—to add unnecessary decoration, detail or embellishment to something that is already complete, beautiful or perfect, often spoiling it in the process. The system works at the moment, and this extra bureaucratic encumbrance for businesses will make it very difficult. It is all very well to troop through the Lobbies to support this legislation, but other people have to pick up the tab—mainly small business.
There will be no limits on or specifications around the length of paid or unpaid time off. It could be open to abuse and could be extremely costly to employers. As raised by my noble friend, the provisions of paid facility time for DEI representatives are broad and fairly novel. The code of practice acknowledges:
“Many employers have well-established ways of engaging their workers on equality issues”.
That work has already been done. I ask the question: why is there a carve-out for DEI? Is it not the case that trade unions already have practices and policies which are focused on equality of opportunity and DEI for all the workforce? Why do we need a special, de facto, taxpayer-funded DEI carve-out?
The word “reasonable” in relation to time off is open to highly subjective interpretation and will likely give rise to costly disputes. We absolutely know that that will happen. Where employees hold multiple union roles, their entitlement to time off may compound. The accommodation and facilities provision requirements could also be extremely costly and onerous. I will add, in passing, that the number of responses for this code of practice is extremely small, given that the ramifications through the years and the impact on the efficiency of business will be profound.
I have some specific questions for the Minister about the Explanatory Memorandum for the code of practice. Paragraph 5.1 rather blithely says:
“This will lead to improved worker representation and industrial relations by giving trade union representatives the freedom to organise, represent and negotiate on behalf of their workers, and increased cooperation between employers and workers, leading to beneficial outcomes”.
That is subjective: there is no evidence for it. How is that measured? What is the source? What is the source for the statement:
“Evidence suggests that representatives cannot always take sufficient time off or facilities to carry out their duties. This can limit effective worker representation”?
Where is the example of that? Where is the actual, documented, empirical data that supports those assertions made in the Explanatory Memorandum that accompanies the code of practice we are discussing?
The Explanatory Memorandum also states:
“This approach supports clarity and consistency, enabling the framework to be applied by employers and union representatives in a way that reflects the needs of their workplace”.
Again, no specific evidence is brought forward for that.
Further, when we look at the impact on businesses, charities and voluntary bodies, described on page 4 of the Explanatory Memorandum, there is no real analysis of the impact that the increased facility time will have in terms of familiarisation and transition costs. Although I accept that it will not affect small and micro-businesses, it will still affect businesses which are smaller.
I have to say also that this code of practice is unnecessary. The system at the moment works. This change is one that business is not pressing for. This is a payback for the trade unions, for the money they have given to the Labour Party. I deeply regret it, because it will have huge consequences. It will cost people their jobs, and business opportunity and profits, and that will be bad for the wider economy.