L

Lord Leong (Lab)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 14 October 2026

Debate

Trade Unions (Right to Access Workplaces) Regulations 2026

Contribution

My Lords, let me first thank all noble Lords for their contributions. I am grateful for some support across the House on the Trade Unions (Right to Access Workplaces) Regulations 2026 and the draft code of practice on trade union right of access. Before I answer some of the points raised, I will start by respectfully saying to the noble Lord, Lord Sharpe, and some noble Lords on the opposite side, that the Employment Rights Act has sometimes been portrayed as if workers’ and employers’ interests sit on opposite sides of the ledger. I do not see it that way. This Act is a small but important step in the right direction, establishing a stronger floor for the labour market and greater security for working people. Good employers should not fear a race to the top. Many already go well beyond the statutory minimum. I said earlier that I spent 45 years in business. I know that the relationship between an employer and the staff is central to success. People who feel valued and secure have a stronger stake in helping that business succeed. I just want to put that on the record. The whole point about union representation and employers is for them to come together to address issues. Let me also share some statistics. Workplace conflict currently costs employers almost £30 billion a year, equivalent to £20,000 per employee. In 2022-23, the UK lost more days to strikes than any year since the 1980s, and NHS strikes in 2023 alone cost the taxpayer more than £1 billion. Access under a statutory access agreement cannot be used for the purposes of ongoing industrial action. Industrial action should and must always be the last resort. The Government believe that better communication between employers, workers and trade unions can help support more stable workplace relations. Now, let me address the issue of SMEs, and let us look at the statistics: 99% of businesses, or 5.5 million businesses, employ fewer than 21 workers. Companies that employ fewer than 21 workers will not have to provide access, because that is what the regulations say. The Government have been clear that SMEs should not face disproportionate burdens under the statutory access framework. That is why the regulation provides that the CAC must refuse access where the employer has fewer than 21 workers, which covers 5.5 million businesses in this country. The threshold aligns with the existing statutory recognition framework, providing consistency across closely related areas of trade union law. The noble Lord, Lord Sharpe, mentioned double standards. Let me be clear again: the enforcement regime applies to trade unions, and the CAC can fine both trade unions and businesses. Businesses and trade unions are both subject to the same enforcement regime. Several noble Lords asked about the consultation. Concerns about proportionality, operational impacts, and the position of SMEs were among the most frequently raised issues throughout the consultation. These concerns were considered carefully, and we made a number of changes to improve clarity, workability, and the practical applicability of the framework. The final code contains stronger guidance as a result. The noble Lord, Lord Sharpe, asked how the CAC can assess national security. I gently remind the noble Lord that the CAC is an independent statutory regulator, comprising 45 members acting independently, and it will consider evidence, including from employers and unions, on national security issues, where relevant. I will address the point made by the noble Lord, Lord Jackson, about school support and social care. To ensure that the statutory right of access framework operates sufficiently effectively alongside the national bargaining framework, such as for adult social care and school support staff, we intend to introduce a targeted assessment from 2027, so that the size-based threshold does not apply in these cases. On the issue raised by the noble Lord, Lord Ashcombe, on the consultation responses, many more businesses than trade unions were likely to respond to this consultation, because there are far more businesses than unions. Trade unions represent millions of workers when they reply to a consultation with a single response. On the issue of access which the noble Lord, Lord Goddard, raised, access takes place under an agreed arrangement, or an agreement determined by the CAC. The framework sets up where, when and how access may be exercised. Union officials may be required to comply with reasonable workplace instructions, identification requirements, safeguarding arrangements, and health and safety procedures. The framework contains safeguards to ensure that access is meaningful, while taking account of the operational requirements of the workplace. These measures are intended to strike a fair and proportionate balance. They clarify how access should operate, encouraging employers and trade unions to resolve issues through discussions and regulation. As we discussed earlier, the purpose of the framework is not simply to facilitate access, it is to support constructive industrial relations. That is why we have committed to reviewing the framework following implementation. Throughout today’s debate, noble Lords have reflected on the regret amendment tabled by the noble Lord, Lord Sharpe of Epsom. Those concerns centred on the framework’s impact on employers, the weekly access model, and enforcement proportionality. I hope that I have showed that those issues were carefully considered in developing the framework and are reflected in the regulations and the code of practice. As I said earlier, as Minister for Small Business, I recognise the need to avoid disproportionately burdening the smallest employers. The CAC must refuse statutory access for employers with fewer than 21 workers. I hope that the House will support the regulations and the company code of practice.

More from Lord Leong (Lab)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.