B

Baroness Harding of Winscombe (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 13 October 2026

Debate

Health Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I congratulate all five noble Lords making their maiden speeches today, but it is a particular privilege to follow the excellent maiden speech of the noble Lord, Lord Wormald. Many in this House will have had the experience, either as civil servants or Ministers, of the noble Lord’s calm wisdom and quick wit, both of which we have seen already today. They will add considerably to the work of the House. Personally, I can honestly say, having worked alongside the noble Lord literally every hour of every day during the Covid pandemic, that despite his insistence that “Yes Minister” was in fact a training video, he has public service values second to none. Under extraordinary pressure he is calm and thoughtful and always finds time for the team around him. As we have seen today, the noble Lord, Lord Wormald, thinks deeply about the most important issues in our society: our education and our healthcare services. As such, I know that he has already played a significant role in improving the lives of people, young and old, across the country, and I have no doubt that he will continue to do so as a Member of this House. In his quiet and thoughtful way, the noble Lord, Lord Wormald, has also said some important things about this Bill. We pride ourselves in this House in going into detail that the other place does not, and in doing so, we all like to think that we improve legislation. Often that is true, but we can also go down cul-de-sacs or adorn Bills with Christmas decorations and get distracted from the real problems a Bill is trying to address. As many have already said, those of us who have been in this House for a while know that health Bills are particularly susceptible to this. It is important that we keep in mind the three shifts that so many people have referenced today: to community, to data and digital—even I am now forgetting the third one—underpinned fundamentally by patients. I want to make three points about the Bill. The first is about the shifting of the organisational deckchairs. In my career in business and in public service, I am always sceptical that restructuring things will actually solve a problem. We must ask ourselves whether, in centralising everything in the Department of Health and Social Care, we are centralising and decentralising the right functions. My experience with the NHS is that, more often than not, it gets it back to front. It is clear to me that digital things need to be centralised, but the decisions on who the right people are to run organisations out in systems, as the noble Lord, Lord Stevens, said earlier, is highly unlikely to be to be taken well in Whitehall. I am supportive of reducing the number of people working in NHS organisations that do not actually serve patients, of which NHS England is a very large example. It is right to create one central organisation in the Department of Health, but we need to be challenging. Are we putting the accountabilities in the right place? Are we pushing subsidiarity down as much as possible? And are we clear that it serves patients? Secondly, on the single patient record, the clue is in the name: are we designing it for patients or for vested interests in the system? The trust that patients need to have in the data architecture of our healthcare system is going to be key. Although it is only one clause, Clause 52, I think we are going to spend a huge amount of time scrutinising it. Personally, I would like to see clearer indications of who will be consulted and how they will be consulted. At the moment, in Clause 52(6) the Secretary of State can consider whoever they think is appropriate in their consultation. That is alarming, because the system does not usually consult patients enough. With the third area, again the clue is in the name: the patient’s voice. Like many others today, I am concerned about the abolition of Healthwatch—not because it is a panacea, because, as others have said, it is not. I come from the consumer business world, and compared to other consumer or citizen services, I think we all know that healthcare is not very good at listening to its users and patients. Even the best parts of our healthcare system tend to be quite paternalistic and think they know better than patients. I cannot get my head around how abolishing Healthwatch is going to make that better. I hope that through the course of this Bill, as the Minister said in her introduction, we will engage in a constructive debate on how we turbocharge the patient’s voice through our health and care system rather than the opposite. There is undoubtedly enormous experience in this House on health and social care, and I very much look forward to working with everyone on this. As I started, I would like to finish: I hope that we will focus our healthcare system on the shift to community, the shift to prevention and the shift to digital—I remembered it this time.

More from Baroness Harding of Winscombe (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.