L

Lord Rooker (Lab)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 13 October 2026

Debate

Health Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I will not detain the House, but this is an identical amendment to the one I moved to the two previous Bills: the Representation of the People Bill and the Hillsborough Bill. Basically, the idea is to strengthen the role of the elected Members of the Commons. It is not to attack the Commons; it is to strengthen their role. They are in a position where every Bill is guillotined there under a programme Motion. We started it in 1997 and it was a good idea then but, like all good ideas, it has got a bit iffy, because the effect is that the Government always want to boast about the numbers of Bills, at the expense of the scrutiny of the Bills. For the Bills arriving in this House, as a result of inadequate scrutiny we end up sending far more amendments back to the Commons than would otherwise be the case. When they arrive down there, the Government Whips complain to the elected Members that it is all the fault of the upper House and we need reform. But, basically, reform in the Commons is needed. When we return amendments to the elected Members, their time is limited due to the original programme Motion. So they need more time for scrutiny. Effectively, the Government have taken some powers from Parliament that they ought to give back. I am asking for a list, and the Government have it, by the way, because the Bill team must have it. Noble Lords can work it out for themselves. The Bill team will know what has been added to the Bill that was not debated. Briefly, what is in this Bill that the Commons has not scrutinised is not as clear as it is for the two previous Bills that I have drawn to the attention of the House. Report was over two days in the Commons. Two days —that is great. The programme Motion was changed from the one originally set out. Day 1 was Monday 7 September and the proceedings are normally chopped at 10 pm—that is normal. But the Bill did not start until 7.26 pm because the Government laid no fewer than three Statements, with no injury time for the Bill. That is the point. Between 7.26 pm and 10 pm, the Commons dealt with 50 new clauses and more than 40 amendments. They occupied 44 columns of Hansard, in two and a half hours. You cannot really be certain about how many were added to the Bill from just looking at the Hansard; it is not possible. Day 2 was on Tuesday 8 September. The start was 4.45 pm and the chop was 6 pm. Noble Lords heard that correctly: 6 pm. In one and a quarter hours, there were at least five new government clauses, 25 other new clauses and 20 amendments, some of which were government amendments. At the 6 pm chop, another six new government clauses were added on the nod to the Bill—that can be seen clearly. I am not certain about any amendments. For day 2, I did not count the columns in Hansard; I think I have made my point about the first day. The total time on Report was less than four hours. That is the reality. So, when the time comes later this year or early next year with these Bills—when we get in a tussle with the other House about the amendments we are sending and when threats are made—I want a good audit trail of what we have tried to do. We are trying to strengthen the Commons so that we end up with less work to send back to them, giving them the chance to scrutinise the Bills properly, rather than putting into Bills massive numbers of new clauses that have never ever been debated. That is a crazy way to do legislation. I cannot believe that someone is not advising the Prime Minister that we will come unstuck on this. I beg to move.

More from Lord Rooker (Lab)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.