B

Baroness Falkner of Margravine (CB)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 19 October 2026

Debate

Public Office (Accountability) Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I wish to make some observations on the amendment. In doing so, I declare an interest, in that I am a distinguished fellow of the think tank Policy Exchange, which published a report on this Bill called Legislating for Candour? only last week. My main remarks have to do with subsection (9) of the new text for Clause 10 proposed by the noble Lord, Lord Alton of Liverpool. In my understanding, it is intended to cover circumstances where the holder of a public office ceases to hold it, ceases to be employed by the public sector, or resigns, is relieved or is dismissed—in other words, is no longer effectively there to be accountable for their actions. I share the outrage that the public feel when people who are so clearly implicated in wrongdoing resign, generally on full pay, or move on or out, at the first whiff of having to account for their actions, and there is very little that can be done. I completely appreciate that; however, I wonder whether, in proposing this long and comprehensive new text to replace subsections (3) to (14), the proposers might have thought to do this in a different way. For example, instead of defining comprehensively in subsections (9) and (10) all the circumstances where an officeholder may no longer be in post, certain actions of the officeholder, rather than the circumstances, could be the subject of scrutiny, enforcement and sanctions. I say this because I have some experience of arm’s-length bodies and other regulators, notably as a former chair of the Equality and Human Rights Commission. My personal experience is also informed by some work I did at the Bank of England, where for nine years I was a member of the enforcement decision-making committee. I will come to that when I move another amendment. The point I want to share with the Committee is that, when you are a public official and you take actions in good faith, you take them on the basis of advice you have received individually, or indeed collectively, in discussions with other employees of that organisation, other board members and so on, perhaps even including external legal advice. Once you depart that organisation, all your records, electronic or otherwise, do not belong to you; they belong to the public body you served. You have a requirement to hand in all your records, documents, discussions, informal advice, formal advice. I recall that, at one point at EHRC, that requirement also included Post-it notes. The challenge became identifying which Post-it note that had come unstuck from a document belonged to which page of which document. It can be quite a tortuous process. The arguments that informed your decision, which may have been made several years prior, are not yours to re-examine in trying to work out why you took the actions you took. You do not have an audit trail as an individual; all you have is memory and, hopefully, other witnesses who might have been in the room at the time and whom you have good relations with and can still contact in the hope that they will come to your rescue. The obligations arising from your earlier responsibility apply to you subsequently, according to this amendment, but you may have very little in terms of a defence. I appreciate that the signatories to the amendment agree that a consultation would be carried out on any regulations the Government drew up, but I prefer the Government’s own drafting of this Bill, which is fairly muscular in describing the code and seems to have been well thought through. I am not entirely convinced by the amendment. A final question I have for the Government relates to the overarching obligation arising from the core code in Clause 10(3). This question has arisen throughout my reading of the Bill. We know that the former Prime Minister, Sir Keir Starmer, directed the Cabinet Secretary, Dame Antonia Romeo, to conduct an overarching review of the Civil Service’s Code of Conduct. We know that the review is ongoing; I think she expects to report next year. One of the principal things the review will do is to look at several of the areas of the Bill relating to the duty of candour, specifically the seven Nolan principles. The Civil Service Code as it stands—and it is likely, if anything, to be strengthened—covers honesty, accountability and integrity. In one of our earlier debates today, on the destruction of public records, I was tempted to ask about integrity, but I did not wish to detain the Committee unnecessarily. I was tempted to point out that civil servants already have an obligation not to destroy but to hold all records; that comes under the duty of integrity clearly set out in the Civil Service Code. My question for the Minister is: what will happen to that review and its relationship with this core code, and how will the two interact, or will the core code take precedence over the Civil Service Code? I say that advisedly because currently—and I disagree with the practice—not only does the Civil Service Code hold and apply to all civil servants but it allows different government departments to layer on and add their own separate codes, depending on their functions. We are potentially going to have a three-tier adherence to codes on the part of civil servants. One will be the departmental code, the second the overarching Civil Service Code and the third the codes envisaged in the Bill. I wonder whether the Government have reviewed how those three different aspects of ethical standards will apply to the 6 million or so civil servants, plus all non-departmental public bodies and arm’s-length bodies.

More from Baroness Falkner of Margravine (CB)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.