L

Lord Marks of Henley-on-Thames (LD)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 19 October 2026

Debate

Public Office (Accountability) Bill

Contribution

My Lords, we on these Benches have been clear that we greatly welcome the Bill, but we wish to strengthen it. We believe that Amendment 35 and the introduction of a common code would add strength to the Bill and reinforce its effect. In view of the disgraceful cover-ups relating to so many of the tragedies discussed in relation to the Bill, from Hillsborough onwards—Horizon, infected blood, Grenfell, Windrush and a shaming number of others—it is unsurprising that the public rationale and justification for the Bill have been founded in later cover-ups of past tragedies, which have been aimed at diverting blame for what happened away from those wholly or partly responsible. The Bill with these aims is laudable, but it could and should do so much more. Its importance lies not only in investigating and inquiring into the reasons why tragedy has happened; equally important is the ambition that the Bill should set enforceable standards for the conduct of officials in an effort to ensure that such tragedies are prevented before they ever happen, and that those standards should be enforced by reference to the criminal law. In this, I echo the words of the noble Lord, Lord Bichard, and others on this issue. The ambition is there in the Bill. It is in the Long Title, which imposes “a duty on public authorities and public officials to act with candour, transparency and frankness … to require public authorities to promote and take steps to maintain ethical conduct within all parts of the authority”. There is no limit in the Long Title confining the duty to inquiries and investigations. While Chapter 1 of Part 2 of the Bill deals with inquiries and investigations, the chapter that we are now considering—Chapter 2 of Part 2, and Clause 10 in particular—deals more generally with standards of ethical conduct, and it is far too weak in its enforcement. Clause 2, which the principal amendments in this group seek to amend, provides principally that a public authority must promote and take steps to maintain high standards of ethical conduct at all times by people who work in the authority. It then sets out what is essentially a restatement of the Nolan principles, which were set out in 1995. We on these Benches believe that this part of the Bill as drafted lacks the teeth needed to enforce standards across public life so as to avoid likely tragedies before they occur. We want the Bill to seize the opportunity to raise standards across public life in real terms. The Bill has often been described as requiring a change of culture, but for that it needs teeth to bite at all times. By our amendments we seek to make Chapter 2 of Part 2 as strong and important as Chapter 1 on inquiries and investigation. The Nolan principles are laudable and right but they have been around since 1995, and in principle long before then, yet these tragedies have happened. The principles need serious underpinning. On the code, we support Amendment 35, which would provide, as the noble Lord, Lord Alton, explained, for a single national core code. That code would be—as it has to be—underpinned by regulations. It would establish not only the principles and the standards, but the practical application of those standards and procedures for their implementation and enforcement. The core code would not preclude specific bodies from promulgating and enforcing particular codes to supplement the core code where those are appropriate. There may well be good reason for such additional supplemental provisions, usually applicable to particular types of authority or areas of operation, but they should always be consistent with the core code. Amendment 61 would make it clear that guidance specific to particular authorities must be consistent with the core code of conduct, and that no public authority may substitute its own code for the core code. But our starting point for this group is that we should avoid multiple different codes—one adopted by each different public authority—and aim to achieve a single set of standards in much more detail than the Nolan principles, applicable to the whole of public life and all officials. We see the prime advantages of this arrangement as being far more likely with a core code than with multiple divergent codes to command universal understanding of the standards expected of public officials. A core code would lead to far more consistency. It would avoid conflicts between the codes of different bodies. What is okay for Hampshire should not differ from what is okay for North Yorkshire. A single core code would be likely to lead to a code of higher quality than multiple and divergent codes, if only because the concentrated expertise devoted to its compilation would lead to a better and more studied core code and more focused individual supplementary codes where necessary. A single code, moreover, would lead to a build-up of a single, comprehensible and authoritative body of case law, and experience of what works and how standards should properly be applied. Multiple codes, which might conflict, might risk the growth of satellite litigation where codes differ. A single code would save resources—the noble Lord, Lord Murray, made that point—with one body established for drafting and updating it as the need arises. For every public body to have working parties to set up their own divergent codes and later to update them, no doubt at different times, would be a recipe for divergence and chaos. It would undermine public respect for the whole project and would be grossly wasteful of resources. Amendment 51, to which I have added my name, would require a consultation and report on the code within a short timetable. The timetable has to be tight for a reason. These standards need to be in place quickly. We need to avoid further failures in our public life that damage so many lives and that demean the reputation of the United Kingdom for competent, fair and honest administration. We must recover that reputation, and this Bill could be a way to do so with a core code. I add nothing to what my noble friend Lady Hamwee said on Amendment 36 about the need for involvement of the independent public adviser, which is plainly sensible and right. This is an important group in making this significant Bill work in practice. I fear, along with others, that without a common core code—one that is clear, widely publicised, understood and applicable across the country, backed up by enforcement provisions and provisions of the criminal law—we will betray the hopes and the justified demands of past victims. Without it, we will risk selling out on the opportunity for this Bill to make actual adherence to high ethical standards a real achievement rather than an unrealised pipe dream.

More from Lord Marks of Henley-on-Thames (LD)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.