L

Lord Reay (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 19 October 2026

Debate

Railways Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I thank all noble Lords who have spoken in this debate. If the Government are going to create a new Passengers’ Council that is funded with public money, value for money must be built into its operation from the outset. That is why we strongly support Amendment 186, which was tabled by my noble friend Lord Evans of Guisborough. For the same reason, we cannot support Amendments 184A and 204C from the noble Baroness, Lady Jones of Moulsecoomb. These amendments would remove the cost-efficiency duties from the Passengers’ Council and London TravelWatch respectively. If these bodies are spending taxpayers’ money, we see no justification for removing an express requirement to consider the efficient use of those funds. Other amendments in this group discuss the relationship between the Passengers’ Council and the ORR. The Government repeatedly tell us that the ORR will remain a strong and robust independent regulator, yet, under Clause 42, when the Passengers’ Council refers a contravention to the ORR, the regulator can simply report back on what action, if any, it proposes to take—including its reasons for taking no action. Amendments 191 to 193 in the name of my noble friend Lord Evans would give that relationship some bite by requiring the ORR to take action where a contravention has been referred to it by the statutory passenger watchdog. If the Passengers’ Council has identified a genuine contravention that is serious enough to be referred to the regulator, why does the Bill expressly contemplate the supposedly robust regulator doing nothing? Amendment 187 in the name of my noble friend Lord Evans would require the Secretary of State and GBR to respond within one month to representations from the council. Amendment 188 would require an annual assessment of passenger satisfaction. Amendments 194 and 195 would require investigation reports to be published and would impose a six-month deadline for publication. The noble Baroness, Lady Jones, makes a reasonable transparency point in Amendment 202A, which would require substantive written advice from the council to be published, subject to a sensible public interest exception. One would hope that much of this is what the Government intend to do anyway. Lastly, Amendment 333A in the name of my noble friend Lord Moylan concerns the appointment of the chair of the Passengers’ Council. In February, the Transport Committee recommended that the preferred candidate should face a pre-appointment hearing specifically to reinforce the watchdog’s independence from both the Secretary of State and GBR; it pointed to comparable arrangements for bodies including the Patient Safety Commissioner, the Housing Ombudsman and the Children’s Commissioner. The Transport Committee already conducts pre-appointment scrutiny of the chairs of the ORR and the Civil Aviation Authority. I very much welcome, therefore, the Minister’s decision, which was confirmed this week, to accept the committee’s recommendation and pursue adding the chair of the Passengers’ Council to the list of posts that are subject to pre-appointment scrutiny. Amendment 333A would simply put that safeguard into legislation. Given that the Government now accept the principle, I would be grateful if the Minister could explain whether she is prepared to accept the amendment; if so, how; and on what timetable the Government intend to give effect to their new commitment.

More from Lord Reay (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.