L

Lord Harlech (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 20 October 2026

Debate

Armed Forces Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I declare my interest as a serving officer in the Army Reserve. I will speak to Amendment 2 in my name and that of my noble friend Lady Fraser of Craigmaddie. I also take this opportunity to send my best wishes to the noble Lord, Lord Coaker, and my noble friend Lady Goldie, and to welcome the Minister to her place. This amendment merges the two that I tabled in Committee and confines them to health bodies alone. That change answers the Minister’s objection in Committee, which was that national authorities and Ministers make decisions about the Armed Forces community in general, rather than about individuals. However, where a health body is dealing with an individual, it would have to establish and record whether that person is a serving reservist, although answering would remain voluntary and a refusal could not affect any treatment. The body would then be required to have due regard to that person’s need to meet the medical and dental fitness standards required for callout. Clinical need would continue to govern treatment decisions throughout, and reserve status could be weighed only as between patients of equivalent clinical priority, so the provision is a tie-break which cannot displace a single patient with a greater clinical need. Let me deal at the outset with the Minister’s point in Committee that the amendment would require preference irrespective of the needs of everyone else. With respect, it would not, and the text before the House says so in clear terms. The case for the amendment rests on two things. The first is that the duty in Clause 2 cannot operate on a cohort that nobody can see. In Committee, my noble friend Lady Goldie asked the noble Lord the Minister directly whether the obligation lies on the reservist to declare or on the body to ask, and the answer was neither. He told the House that it was not the reservist’s responsibility and that the Government regard identification as good practice to be encouraged through guidance rather than a statutory requirement. So we are creating a statutory duty of “due regard” while declining to provide the means of exercising it. The Minister also told the Committee that the recording of someone’s Armed Forces status does not always happen as it could or should, and I agreed with him. The National Health Service has had a clinical code for reservists for four years, but it is barely used. In my own service, I have never once been asked when booking a medical or dental appointment whether I am a member of the Armed Forces. The second reason is capability. This Bill extends liability to serve, with recall, to the age of 65 and a lower threshold for mobilisation. Each of those provisions assumes that the individual is fit to deploy. The Minister confirmed in Committee that reservists will not be mobilised unless they meet the relevant service medical standards. That is precisely the point, because a reservist who cannot obtain a dental appointment fails that standard and becomes non-deployable. That is not just an inconvenience but a capability loss: one the state has created by asking that person to be ready in the first place. My noble friend Lady Fraser gave the Committee the clearest illustration when her daughter, whom I have the honour of serving alongside in 1st Battalion London Guards, received callout papers for Kenya with the Welsh Guards. She had been waiting for treatment for a wisdom tooth and was very nearly undeployable, were it not for the rules being adapted. I asked the Minister two questions in Committee and received answers to neither. What is the department’s assessment of the proportion of trained reservists who are currently medically or dentally non-deployable? Will the Government publish the fitness standards irrespective of what happens to this amendment? Nobody can have due regard to a standard that they are not permitted to see. This amendment creates no charge on public funds, so I look forward to hearing what the noble Baroness has to say in light of it. From the conversations I have had with other noble Lords outside of the Chamber, I feel that there is growing concern over this issue and that the Government and the Ministry of Defence need to start taking some action.

More from Lord Harlech (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.