Contribution
My Lords, I will begin by addressing Amendment 8. I thank the noble Baroness, Lady Brinton, for her views and contribution to this debate, and to the debate throughout Committee. I join her in thanking Aurora New Dawn and the Suzy Lamplugh Trust for their invaluable work on this very important issue, which I think has aided all noble Lords’ consideration of it.
I will deal first with the issue of specialist stalking training. The service police are already trained to nationally recognised standards. The Defence Serious Crime Command maintains alignment with the College of Policing’s professionalising investigation programme, and our service police receive offence-specific training aligned with the College of Policing’s standards. We will build on these arrangements, with stalking-specific training for not only service police but front-line personnel. This will enable personnel to recognise stalking behaviours, understand escalation and risk, and apply and enforce the new orders effectively.
Amendment 7A, from the noble Baroness, Lady Brinton, proposes a multi-agency stalking intervention programme —MASIP. A statutory MASIP model would not be practical in the service context. Cases may involve different jurisdictions across the UK and overseas, where local provision and responsibilities vary. Prescribing a single programme in legislation could constrain the flexibility needed to assemble the right partners around each case, leading to duplication of existing safeguarding arrangements and uncertainty over accountability. However, we recognise the importance of multi-agency working and information sharing. Our violence against women and girls taskforce will draw on expertise from across government and the wider VAWG sector to connect multi-disciplinary networks, and it will work closely with the Victim Witness Care Unit. Together, they will deliver risk management and victim protection.
Turning to Amendment 9, the Bill already provides continuity of protection. A service stalking protection order will automatically convert into a civilian stalking protection order when the person ceases to be subject to service law or service discipline, removing the need for a new order. That legal continuity is supported by existing operational arrangements. The Defence Serious Crime Command’s public protection unit can notify civilian forces when an order is imposed. Service police can also share information through public protection notices, national policing systems, and direct liaison with civilian public protection units and the service police’s 24-hour operations room. These mechanisms ensure that responsibility for enforcement can pass between jurisdictions without interrupting protection. Training, referrals and information sharing are better maintained through guidance and operational practice so they can be updated quickly as risks and policing practice evolve. We will continue to work with specialist organisations—the Military Court Service, the service police, the Armed Forces, and civilian partners—to design and implement effective training, guidance and support to victims across the defence establishment.
The Government recognise the concerns raised about the operation of these orders, and the intention behind proposed new Clause 7B, which would require annual reports on progress on addressing stalking in the Armed Forces. To reassure the noble Baroness, Lady Brinton, the Government will commit to update Parliament on the effectiveness of service stalking protection orders 12 months after the provisions have been commenced.
Turning to Amendment 10 and the victims’ code, all victims within the service justice system are entitled to support under the code for victims in the service justice system should they choose to receive it, irrespective of the nature of the offence committed against them. This includes victims of sexual offences and domestic abuse, where specialist support is available. The code for victims in the service justice system provides parity with the statutory rights for victims in England and Wales. It will contain the same key principles within legislation, set out in Clause 11, and the same 12 rights to ensure that victims of service offences and civilian victims receive equivalent standards, protections and entitlements.
If a service person is a victim whose case is being investigated by the civilian criminal justice system, defence policy gives personnel the right to comprehensive welfare support, including specialist welfare, delivered by trained staff where necessary, regardless of the civilian criminal justice system outcome. The Victim Witness Care Unit is well placed to support those who are dealt with in the service justice system by providing information and updates as the case progresses, through dedicated victim liaison officers—but it does not provide welfare support. Extending the remit of the Victim Witness Care Unit to victims in the criminal justice system would not materially change the services provided to such victims.
Government Amendments 11 to 15 simply give effect to the Delegated Powers and Regulatory Reform Committee’s recommendation that the code for victims in the service justice system receive the same level of parliamentary scrutiny as the civilian code for victims in England and Wales. I am pleased that the noble Baroness, Lady Brinton, and the Opposition Front Bench recognise this as progress.
Turning to government Amendments 44, 45 and 46, I thank the right reverend Prelate the Bishop of Norwich for raising this important issue in Committee. The Government welcome the intent of these proposals—indeed, I believe they are welcome across your Lordships’ House—and agree that they will have a positive impact and continue to provide the necessary and important protections for our service police. As a result, the Government have tabled the following amendments.
Amendment 44 amends the Assaults on Emergency Workers (Offences) Act 2018 to list the service police as emergency workers within Section 3. Additionally, it ensures consistency by including the service police in the equivalent legislation in Scotland: the Emergency Workers (Scotland) Act 2005. This will provide prosecutors with an additional offence to consider, as appropriate, where incidents of assault on service police are reported. Subsequently, Section 68 of the Sentencing Act 2020 is amended to include service police. This again defines emergency workers for the purposes of this Act, where Section 67 requires courts to treat offences committed against emergency workers as an aggravating factor that increases the seriousness of that crime.
Amendment 45 applies Section 90 of the Police Act 1996 to members of the service police forces and provides that, in its application to service police, Section 90 has effect throughout England and Wales and Scotland. For Northern Ireland, Amendment 46 applies Section 67 of the Police (Northern Ireland) Act 1998 to members of the service police. Taken together, these provisions mean that the relevant impersonation offences will apply in each of the three UK legal jurisdictions.
I hope this provides the necessary reassurances to the right reverend Prelate the Bishop of Norwich, and so I hope he feels able not to press his amendments and support those the Government have brought forward to address his concerns. I also hope that my previous comments gave enough assurance to the noble Baroness, Lady Brinton, so that she will not press hers.