B

Baroness Antrobus (Lab)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 20 October 2026

Debate

Armed Forces Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I am grateful to those who have contributed to the debate on this group. I thank the noble Lord, Lord Harlech, for his amendment, and the noble Baroness, Lady Fraser, for introducing the amendment and making its case. I listened with care and I will try to address a couple of her points as we go through. In fact, to that end, the MoD, as the noble Baroness acknowledged, works closely with employers to promote the benefits of reservists to companies, and many actively recognise this; hence, as was mentioned, the silver and gold schemes. My noble friend Lord Coaker went into more detail, so I will just leave that there, but they have their place, without doubt. More than 9,000 companies are part of the employee recognition scheme, which requires employers to have reserve-positive policies in their workplace. We also have a number of existing statutory safeguards in place to ensure that reserves are protected when we mobilise them. We are not complacent: as global instability increases and the importance of our Reserve Forces continues to grow, we are committed to improving reservists’ readiness. However, we believe this must be done in partnership with employers and industry, whose ongoing support remains vital to the future success of the reserves. While I accept that some businesses, such as that of the noble Baroness, Lady Fraser, would welcome this amendment, I take the point of the noble Earl, Lord Minto, that there are problems with potentially increasing costs on business as well. For that reason, we do not believe that these amendments strike the right balance. To address the points made by the noble Baroness, Lady Smith of Newnham, the Government remain committed to ensuring that reservists are supported and not unfairly disadvantaged. The concern is not with the principle of supporting reservists, but with whether the amendments are the right legal mechanism. The Government believe that employer engagement, covenant commitments—as was mentioned—and targeted support are more appropriate and proportionate than creating a broad new employment status. We feel that the amendment could create uncertainty for employers, particularly small and medium-sized businesses, causing them to worry that they may make ordinary workplace decisions more vulnerable to tribunal claims, even where decisions are based on legitimate operational compliance requirements. That could discourage open discussion about reserve commitments, undermining the partnership approach between defence employers and reserves. Amendment 25 would compel the Secretary of State to undertake a review into tax-free payments for the first 30 days of a reservist’s service each year. While I recognise the intent behind it, I do not consider a statutory review necessary. The Government keep pay and conditions under continuous review, and reservists already benefit from a generous package of support, including a tax-free annual bounty of up to £2,391. Importantly, the Government believe that making reserve pay tax-free would create a significant disparity with our regular personnel. Those of us—and there are perhaps a couple in this Chamber—who remember Pay 2000, which introduced discrepancies and differential pay, and the effect that it had on the Royal Navy, in particular, would, I think, want me to make this point emphatically. We do not want to create a disparity between regular and reserve personnel pay and conditions in this way. I do, however, share the noble Baroness’s commitment to improving reserve recruitment. Our approach to recruitment and retention is to improve the offer.

More from Baroness Antrobus (Lab)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.