B

Baroness Penn (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 20 October 2026

Debate

Armed Forces Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I add my support for Amendment 54, from the noble and gallant Lord, Lord Craig of Radley, on removing fees for indefinite leave to remain for families of serving personnel and veterans with a minimum period of service. As the noble and gallant Lord said, families have waited long enough. I will not add to his words, except to say that I hope the MoD has been successful in its work to corral other government departments to finally get this commitment delivered. Like others, I will listen carefully to the Minister’s response. I turn to Amendment 55 on paternity leave. I thank the Minister—and the noble Lord, Lord Coaker, in his absence—for their engagement on this issue. As I said in Committee, this amendment is about how we support military families, but at its heart it is about military capability. I understand that feedback from the services raised concerns about the impact of extending paternity leave on operational capability and effectiveness, and I think it is fair to say there is some scepticism about the importance of this issue to members of the forces and their families. I will take the two points in reverse. Since Committee, the Dad Shift has conducted a survey of over 1,700 members of the military and the MoD, and nearly 1,000 fathers responded. While 95% had taken paternity leave and 92% had taken the full two weeks, 94% felt that two weeks was simply not enough. When asked about retention, of the 544 who responded 35% said that their experience of paternity leave had influenced their thinking about leaving the Armed Forces. This does not match the view reported from service leaders at one of the meetings we had that this is not an issue, particularly for forces families. I am also concerned at the declining take-up of existing paternity leave policies and at what appeared to be a view that this should be seen perhaps as a positive, rather than as a warning sign around culture and workforce issues within our services. Turning to operational capability, I would appreciate greater clarity from the Minister on why—given that paternity leave, like other policies under JSP 760, can be taken only at the service’s discretion, subject to operational requirements—an increase in paternity leave cannot be managed without impacting on operational effectiveness. That must already be the case where discretionary leave is granted—for example, in cases where a birth is via C-section, making up nearly half of all births in our country today. Given that all our major allies manage policies significantly more generous than ours, I would like to understand whether any efforts have been made to understand how they manage the operational impact of those policies, or indeed the benefits they may see on retention within their services. I appreciate the work going on within the MoD to look at this issue further and I understand that focus groups will be conducted across all three services later this month. I would be grateful if the Minister could confirm that these will be focused specifically on parental leave and paternity leave in particular, and that the results of these focus groups will be made public and available to Parliament. To follow up on that work, will the MoD commit to questions on parental leave and paternity leave specifically being included in the next tri-services families continuous attitude survey, in 2027? It would also be useful to hear further information about the planned awareness-raising activities for the families day in November. At Second Reading, I referenced the workforce crisis highlighted by the strategic defence review, a crisis not just of recruitment but of retention. It is unclear to me at the moment that the MoD and the services have serious plans to make the changes needed to address this, but I very much hope that I am proven wrong.

More from Baroness Penn (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.