Contribution
My Lords, I have signed Amendment 114. I fully support not only that amendment but Amendment 102, moved by the noble Baroness, Lady Goudie. These amendments are there to make Clause 20 work as intended, supplemented as it is by Parts 4 and 5 of Schedule 6 on legal aid at inquests and at inquiries into fatal accidents and sudden deaths in Scotland.
These provisions have been principally discussed outside this House and the other place as impacting on parity and as being about equality of arms at inquests, but they are also about timing. That was a point well made by the noble Baroness, Lady Goudie, and the noble Lord, Lord Bach, and movingly brought to life additionally by my noble friend Lady Ludford. She highlighted the obvious reality that the early stages of the coronial procedure are the closest to the deaths involved, when the pain and confusion for the bereaved, and the challenges of unfamiliarity with the process, are at their highest.
This is not only about early access on representation; it is, importantly, as my noble friend Lady Ludford said, about investigations. It is also a question of evidence. Late representation means that any evidence-gathering by the families, which needs to be professionally undertaken, may be badly delayed and therefore stale and often less effective. That applies to expert evidence as much as—indeed often more than—it applies to lay evidence. Expert evidence can be contradictory on really important issues, and those relating to deaths may be issues very much in point. Late instruction gives one of the interested parties a very significant and utterly unfair head start, so it is crucial that representation and advice are available from a very early stage from all those points of view.
On the question of representation at hearings, one of the really shaming features of inquests, and I would add of inquiries, particularly but not exclusively after major tragedies, has been the ability of public authorities or their contractors and suppliers, who are in the frame—if I may use that expression—so at risk of being blamed for what has gone wrong, to hire teams of very expensive lawyers, investigators and experts to deploy detailed and complex evidence and arguments to deflect blame from their clients. At the same time, the victims have frequently been unable to afford either any legal representation or any comparable legal representation to ensure that the victims get a proper hearing of the other side of the case and that the evidence on behalf of those putatively responsible is properly examined by the teams available to the bereaved—examined, interrogated and, where necessary, contradicted or undermined during the coronial or inquiry process.
It is similar to the point made in relation to whistleblowers by my noble friend Lady Kramer, which is of alarmingly wide application. Clause 20(1)(d) and (e) are directed at redressing the imbalance between victims and bereaved families and the public authorities which risk being held responsible for fatal disasters. They do so by imposing “an overriding objective” that victims and others
“are able to participate fully and effectively”
in any inquiry or inquest. Clause 20(1)(e) will provide for legal aid
“without a means test, to bereaved family members where a public authority”,
or, as we would say, its private contractors, is involved. I add that in relation to the position of private contractors providing public services to public authorities and the Minister’s response on this point in the last group. I hope we will be able to discuss the position of private contractors within the various provisions of the Bill, because I still find the Government’s position on this issue a little obscure.
While welcome, those sub-sections that I have outlined are not enough to redress the imbalance inherent in the Bill, even as it now stands, or to provide anything like equality of arms or parity. The importance of Amendment 114 is that it would ensure that legal aid rates for inquests are at rates comparable to those paid for the public authority’s legal teams, as the noble Baroness, Lady Chakrabarti, explained in her speech. That amendment may require fleshing out, but the iniquity in this context of unacceptably low rates for legal aid work has to be addressed.
The growth of legal aid deserts—the unavailability of competent lawyers qualified and willing to undertake any heavy civil work at current legal aid rates—has been a scandal on which the noble Lord, Lord Bach, and many of us have frequently spoken in this House. That applies particularly to what we all agree is the complex work which often falls to be tackled in the wake of disasters which have impacted so heavily on the lives and the plain ability to cope of those needing fair, skilled and sympathetic expert representation. It is a particularly egregious failure of our system that the failure to ensure such representation has such a serious effect on the victims of disasters for which our public authorities bear, or may bear, prime responsibility.