Contribution
My Lords, the Government’s first duty is to protect their citizens from harm. This Government are failing in that duty of care for our children. Two years ago, during a debate on the use of puberty blockers, I reminded the House that I had represented Her Majesty’s Opposition through the passage of the Gender Recognition Act. That was 23 years ago. It had been scrutinised in draft form by the Joint Committee on Human Rights and was steered through your Lordships’ House by the then Minister, the noble Lord, Lord Adonis. I had been reassured repeatedly that gender dysphoria affected a tiny number of people in the UK—5,000 at the very most—and that there was no indication, research or medical evidence that this cohort would grow.
Some 23 years on, we are facing the most appalling situation whereby this Government think it is okay to use young children in random clinical trials—experiments—that may and probably will have a lasting and possibly irreversible and seriously harmful physical and/or mental effect upon some or all of those children. There is no scientific evidence to back this experiment up.
I have huge respect for the Minister, who is in a very difficult position. I have considered with care her response and other responses to the recent Oral Question from the noble Baroness, Lady Deech, in your Lordships’ House on 25 June 2026. I find them shocking and revealing. In her initial response, the Minister stated, with regard to the PATHWAYS trial:
“Eligibility is tightly controlled; it requires parental consent, a minimum two-year gender incongruence diagnosis, psychosocial support, and NHS and multidisciplinary team approval, as well as participant understanding of the risks and benefits, physical and mental stability, and compliance with safeguarding requirements”.—[Official Report, 25/6/26; col. 754.]
With respect, this is verbal nonsense designed to mask the reality. Where and what are the safeguards that should govern any administration of these drugs to children? Does this not make a mockery of safeguarding? Seriously, on 11 and 12 year-old participants understanding the risks, how can a prepubescent child comprehend the long-term effects of puberty blockers or hormones? What about legal competence?
There is also, in the answers to Question from the noble Baroness, Lady Deech, a clear message from the Government Benches that this is “not political”. Why is that? This indicates to me that the Government are keen to ensure that this experimenting with young children’s lives is seen as a cross-party exercise—oh, and that includes the bishops. So, when it goes wrong, we can all share the blame. It is wrong—wrong.
In addition, I was shocked to read the contribution from the noble Lord, Lord Cashman, that
“the only thing that matters in this instance is the right of the child to the best and most appropriate treatment”.
Given the possible effects of these drugs, do we defer to the right of a child aged 11 or 12? That is madness. The noble Lord, Lord Scriven, suggested that
“getting an evidence-gathering trial under way would be an effective way to protect them from the dangers of these unregulated and unmonitored markets”.—[Official Report, 25/6/26; col. 755-6.]
So, just because this country is now almost entirely lawless, with scant enforcement, let us experiment on our children, rather than tackle the unregulated—that is, illegal—drugs market. The right reverend Prelate the Bishop of Manchester said that, in effect, experimenting with our children is a handy way of removing the culture wars; it was well meant, I am sure, but all this suggests to me is that it helps to explain the current state of the Church of England. Further, I put it to the Minister—whom, I repeat, I really do respect—that when, in one of her answers, she said that it is
“important to have a cool head”,—[Official Report, 25/6/26; cols. 756.]
she revealed that she is just as apprehensive as the many thousands of others who cannot understand the mindset of those pushing this.
I turn briefly to those selected for the so-called trials. Can the Minister tell us, given the Government’s obsession with diversity, equality and inclusion, whether participants include children from different ethnic and religious groups—plus maybe one or two who are directly related to members of this Government? How does it go? The evil that men do lives after them.
I shall end this as I did the last time I spoke on the subject. As a mother, a grandmother and a Peer, I urge the Government to think again and stop this nightmare.