T
The Lord Bishop of St Edmundsbury and Ipswich
Speaking in the House of Lords on 27 October 2026
Debate
Courts and Tribunals BillContribution
My Lords, as a Christian, I believe that justice should be grounded in the recognition that all people, victim and perpetrator alike, possess an unyielding human dignity given to them by God. Today I will focus on how this Bill might serve to uphold that dignity for some of the most vulnerable who encounter our justice system. My right reverend friend the Bishop of Gloucester is unable to be here, but I know that she will follow this Bill closely and will take up these points in Committee.
I express my strong support for the measures in the Bill which would increase the threshold for admission of sexual behaviour evidence in criminal trials. This reform is long overdue. For survivors of sexual offences, the process of reporting and testifying can be deeply harrowing and retraumatising. In too many cases, when sexual offences are reported to the police, previous disclosures of rape and sexual violence are used as evidence of the survivor’s so-called bad character. There are many accounts of the ways in which, during trial, questions about survivors’ sexual history have been used to cast doubt on their credibility. I pay tribute to those who have had to endure such an ordeal.
Around 85% of rape survivors do not report the offence to the police. When those who did not report were asked why, the most common reasons were that they did not think the police could help, that they were embarrassed or that they thought that reporting would be humiliating. These statistics are alarming, but can we really be surprised by them when our justice system is permeated by myths of consent and fabrication?
We know that many survivors will never report to the police, but those who do must be given the confidence that they will be treated with dignity, compassion and fairness. The measures in this Bill, especially those which seek to dispel such myths, will go a long way towards achieving that aim. It is my hope that they will also help foster a culture in which all survivors feel able to come forward, confident that they will be taken seriously and their perpetrators will be held to account.
I am also pleased to see the Government’s focus on tackling the backlog of Crown Court cases, which sees survivors of rape waiting disproportionately lengthy times for their cases to be heard. However, this crisis must not be addressed at the expense of other minoritised communities. While the Government propose that more cases be heard by magistrates’ courts, the eligibility threshold for publicly funded representation there is significantly lower. Unrepresented defendants can suffer serious disadvantages in court, including a limited understanding of the charges they face. This is particularly concerning given the proposal to increase magistrates’ sentencing powers. If these plans are to go forward, they must be implemented with changes to these thresholds from the outset. Without clarity on this in the Bill, we risk embedding economic inequality into our justice system and limiting access to justice for those with the least means.
I am also concerned by the proposal to remove the automatic right of appeal from the magistrates’ court to the Crown Court. As youth justice cases are ordinarily presided over by magistrates, this would have a disproportionate impact on vulnerable young people. The God that I and other Christians worship is one of justice and of mercy. We can express that mercy by offering young people every opportunity at rehabilitation and the chance to turn their lives around. Restricting this right of appeal for children, alongside increased sentencing powers, may be a threat to one of the key safeguards against judicial error. It may serve not only to increase youth imprisonment unnecessarily but to further entrench the disadvantages that often draw children into crime.
Court backlogs are severe, but they have been exacerbated by decades of underinvestment. Addressing this issue by simply restricting the right to jury trials may serve only to erode trust in the system without addressing the underlying issues that have brought us to this breaking point. Women, older and racially minoritised defendants are more likely to opt for jury trial in a Crown Court. Taking away this right therefore affects some groups more than others—groups who are already more likely to experience disadvantage and whose confidence in the system’s fairness may already be fragile. We know that, in their journey through the justice system, defendants face countless deprivations of liberty before any verdict is reached. We should be cautious to take this fundamental choice away before the resolutions that can be attained through sustained funding have been properly explored.
To maintain trust, we should strive for a justice system where vulnerable people who disclose sexual violence can trust that they will be treated with compassion and believed, and people of lower economic means can trust that their income will not define their guilt. If young people are to be given the opportunity to grow into the kinds of citizens who can contribute meaningfully to their communities, they must trust that their communities are committed not only to accountability but to restoration, transformation, and the possibility of a better future. This kind of reform cannot be achieved by a Bill alone; it requires significant and sustained investment and a real commitment to upholding the dignity of all people.
More from The Lord Bishop of St Edmundsbury and Ipswich
Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.
About Hansard
Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.