Contribution
My Lords, it is always a pleasure to follow the noble Lord, Lord Bourne of Aberystwyth; his calm, measured tones are always difficult to follow. I also welcome the introduction of the Bill by the noble Baroness, Lady Smith. She was very clear and put forward a very powerful argument for why the consultation is needed.
Noble Lords will notice I am slightly croaky today—I am not the noble Lord croaker—but I will endeavour to get through this. It was also great to hear the interjection by the noble Lord, Lord Blunkett. The noble Lord and I have known each other through Sheffield politics for well over 20 years. I have been rather worried recently because we have agreed more than we have disagreed, but I am now going back to our normal knocking 10 bells out of each other, as we do in Sheffield politically.
I should own up: I am on the traditional liberal wing of the Liberal Democrats, and we have been waiting for rather a long time for this kind of debate and for reform of the House of Lords. It was the Parliament Act 1911 that promised a second Chamber on a popular, rather than hereditary, basis. That was 115 years ago. I would guess it is probably the longest-running temporary arrangement in British public life. I welcome the progress so far in this Parliament: the hereditaries have gone, but some have returned quite rightly on their own merit, and the noble Viscount, Lord Stansgate, will be speaking later.
However, that is only tinkering. We have swapped the accident of birth for the accident of who you know and left the Prime Minister’s patronage exactly where it was. A promise to consult without a date attached is the constitutional equivalent of “The cheque is in the post”. The Liberal Democrat position is long-standing: a fully elected second Chamber, chosen by proportional representation, speaking for the nations and regions of the United Kingdom; the primacy of the Commons will be preserved. But this Bill asks only for a consultation. After 115 years, that is hardly a leap in the dark.
Why an elected Chamber? As a matter of principle in a democracy, I believe the right to make law comes from the people. Not one of the Members of this House, no matter how eminent or detailed we are in legislation, has been chosen by the public to sit here. Not one of us can be held to account or removed by them. That is why this House defers to the elected Commons. It knows it has no mandate. An elected second Chamber would be stronger, not weaker, and it would scrutinise with authority and not, as sometimes we do, with an apology.
I am from Sheffield, like the noble Lord, Lord Blunkett. When the Electoral Reform Society last analysed this House by region, just under 6% of Peers lived in Yorkshire and the Humber, whereas 24% lived in London and 21% in the south-east. For the poor north-east, it was 3%; for Wales it was 4%, Scotland 7% and Northern Ireland 2.5%. A Chamber meant to speak for the whole country looks more like a London dinner party, and Yorkshire rarely gets invited.
I want to be fair, though, to the Cross-Benchers. Their Members are recommended by the House of Lords Appointments Commission through an open, merit-based process and many are people of real distinction who add to your Lordships’ House. But look how thin this safeguard is: the commission is asked to find just two non-party Peers a year, it has no veto and no say over numbers, and the Prime Minister can still nominate Cross-Benchers directly. In 2020, the Prime Minister overruled the commission’s advice. In other democracies, expertise advises; it does not hold a lifelong right to legislate.
On the party Benches, it is starker. The commission checks propriety, not merit, and suitability is left to the party. In July, with the previous Prime Minister preparing to leave, 26 new life Peers were announced in one of his final acts. Five of these places went to my own party, so we claim no clean hands, but while this system exists every party uses it, and that is exactly why it must go. A panel that can improve patronage is not one that can supply a mandate. We elect our councillors, our mayors and our devolved Parliaments as a matter of principle. Only at the top of the system do we hand out seats by appointment, which is unusual in any other bicameral system in the world, bar one.
Like the noble Lord, Lord Blunkett, I will skip along now to the Bishops’ Benches; people would be very surprised if I did not. In 26 cases, some of our Members are here by job title. Again, they contribute to the work of the House, but, as a matter of principle, nobody voted for these 26 Bishops. They are here because of the posts they hold in the only institution in the whole country that is guaranteed places in Parliament. The 2021 census found that 46% of people in England and Wales described themselves as Christian and over 30% said they had no religion at all. The Church’s own figures put average Sunday attendance in 2024 at just under 1% of the population of England, so 1% attend the Church, but 26 seats are guaranteed automatically in the UK Parliament.
We are told that the Bishops speak for the nation, as they do on many important issues, and not just for the Church. But the record shows they also speak for the Church: during the passage of the equal marriage Bill, the previous Archbishop of Canterbury welcomed the Church of England’s quadruple lock on marriage and argued to protect it. In 2023, eight Bishops, including one who then sat in this House, signed a submission asking the Government to exempt the confessional from mandatory reporting. Again, that issue has been raised recently.
We have seen a number of occasions when the Bishops have stood up and asked for special privileges in VAT concessions on reforming and doing up churches. When the hereditary Peers Bill came before us, the right reverend Prelate the Bishop of Sheffield, who I admire greatly, spoke against the amendments to reduce the number of Lords spiritual. Turkeys, I am told, do not vote for Christmas, and it seems that Bishops do not vote for fewer Bishops. This is no criticism of the faith or the individuals, but nobody should sit in our legislature by virtue of a job in one church.
I support the Bill and urge the Government to give us a firm date for consulting, rather than a vague nod to do so.