B

Baroness Taylor of Bolton (Lab)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 23 October 2026

Debate

House of Lords (Alternative Second Chamber) Bill [HL]

Contribution

My Lords, I congratulate the noble Baroness, Lady Smith, not only on her good fortune in the Private Member’s Bill ballot but because of the care she has taken in framing this Bill. She has chosen the wording very wisely. I must express solidarity with her, not just because I too grew up on a council estate in the north of an industrial town but because I agreed with many of the things she said—not least about the Bishops, but that is probably for another day. One of the advantages of speaking late in the debate is that you can comment on what other people have said. One of the disadvantages is that much of it has already being said, so there is no point in going over everything again. But I hope that the noble Baroness, Lady Smith, takes some satisfaction from the fact that most of the speakers, with the exception of the odd one, have been very supportive of the idea that she has put forward. I think that pays tribute to the fact that she did not come up with a simple solution or the answer to the question; she simply raised it and took the wording from the Labour manifesto. The starting point should be that we cannot defend the House of Lords in its present form by any constitutional principles. We are not put here on the basis of anything that could vaguely be called a democratic process. That is our vulnerability; that is the great weakness. Although we cannot defend the way we are put here, we quite rightly say very often that somehow this system works and we are able to do the job we are sent here to do—being a revising second Chamber. This House is by no means perfect. Parliamentary systems are by no means perfect. There are many flaws and many changes that are needed, but we do, at least to a certain extent, have a functioning Parliament. That is what we should bear in mind when we are looking to change in the future. Whatever changes we introduce, they have to present a functioning Parliament at the end of the day. There is the real danger of unintended consequences with all the ideas that have been put forward. The noble Baroness mentioned that she had help from students and that some of them were here. She reminded me that when I was a student, I wrote an essay on reform of the House of Lords. I still had it a few years ago, but I have moved house, so I probably do not now. However, I recall that I suggested a regional structure with either indirect or direct elections, and that that would enhance the impact of the regions. I still think that is one of the biggest problems we face in this House and I still believe there is some scope there. There are challenges and there will still be unresolved issues, but I do not think we should dismiss that possibility totally out of hand. One of the problems is that we do not have the regional infrastructure to sustain that kind of approach; that is not to say that things could not be done in the future. The most important point is that, if we are ever to give greater democratic legitimacy to a second Chamber, we have to consider that we may create a situation where we challenge the primacy of the House of Commons. That is the basic problem that is faced so often. Mention has been made that there have been lots of reviews, commissions and committees. People have come up with ideas, and they fall not because of a lack of ideas but because we need a comprehensive approach that produces a functioning Parliament. Mention was made of dispute resolution procedures, which exist in different places, but our legal system is different as well. The noble Lord, Lord Hannan, mentioned that he does not want the Supreme Court to get involved in all this. All these issues have to be treated extremely carefully. We need to look at the issues that the noble Baroness raised, but I hope—I think the noble Lord, Lord Bourne of Aberystwyth, made this point—that, while we wait for a big change, it does not mean that we ourselves should not undertake significant changes. Perhaps I would say that, because I chaired the Retirement and Participation Committee, and I welcome the comments that were made there. There is a lot that Parliament can do to improve its workings, and there is a lot that this House can do to improve its working. We have a consultation on the sitting hours, which are significant, sometimes even more significant for those Members who do not live in London and who need to balance being in this House with other commitments. I do not think that most Members of the House realise the difficulties that non-London Members face in this way. We should look at the changes and making legitimate changes to the other House as to how we can work together. We need to look at the need for more draft legislation and for more post-legislative scrutiny. One thing that we very much need to do is to look at the way we deal with statutory instruments. Many hours are spent looking at SIs, which are never changed. If we had a proper sifting system, we could have a much more efficient system that would benefit Ministers and the House. I say good luck to the noble Baroness, Lady Smith. We have to be realistic about what can be achieved and the timescale. Above all, we have to make sure that what we end up with provides proper accountability and a properly functioning Parliament.

More from Baroness Taylor of Bolton (Lab)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.