B

Baroness Smith of Llanfaes (PC)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 23 October 2026

Debate

House of Lords (Alternative Second Chamber) Bill [HL]

Contribution

My Lords, I thank all Members who participated in the debate, for just over two hours. We have had a really good debate, with lots of interesting viewpoints, but I was, surprisingly, pleased to hear that the majority of Members who spoke today, barring one or two, support reforming this Chamber. Of course, they do so to different degrees—I understand that—but that is a positive reflection and a step forward, so I am grateful to all those who participated. The noble Lord, Lord Hannan, reminded us that all political parties here have made their positions quite well known: they support reform of the House of Lords as well. That is what the position is of all our political parties here. It is just about us getting on with that and making progress. I would like to rebut and clarify a few points raised in some comments by fellow noble Lords in relation to the Bill. The noble Lord, Lord Bourne of Aberystwyth, suggested that the Bill would abolish the House of Lords. I clarify that the first sentence of the Bill states that it is about “the replacement of the House of Lords with an alternative second Chamber”. It is not about having one Chamber in Parliament; it is about the replacement. The noble and learned Lord, Lord Thomas of Cwmgiedd, raised an interesting point about whether we would want to perhaps change the term “replacement”. I chose that term in this Bill because that is what was in the Labour manifesto; that is what they were elected on, so it is important that that terminology is used because there is a public mandate for that position. But I understand that perhaps it could be perceived in other ways so, just to clarify, that is what it is in relation to. Maybe we could discuss that in Committee. Some noble Lords raised gridlock, and that has come up often when we have talked about Lords reform. On gridlock of that type, I believe that, in the reforms that we would bring forward, any arrangement that mirrored the current balance of powers, which could be written into reform as it was previously in the House of Lords reform Bill, could avoid those types of scenarios. Disagreement over legislation is a type of conflict, one which can delay but not terminate a Government. We can write that into our reforms, so I do not think we can use it as a reason not to reform this Chamber. Let me provide clarification on the point raised by the noble Viscount, Lord Stansgate, and the noble Baroness, Lady Finn, on who would be consulted. They both raised the fact that I have not included either this Chamber, the other place or some other stakeholders in the Bill. But, as under Clause 1(2)(e), the Bill is not limiting, so it would be open to the Secretary of State to consult others too. If Members feel particularly strongly that a group has not been represented in the Bill, they could bring forward an amendment in Committee to add that group. However, I would hesitate to do that, because I am pretty sure it is covered under subsection (2)(e). The noble Baroness, Lady O’Grady, looking ahead to an alternative second Chamber, raised the issue of how we look at diversity and its reflection in a future Chamber. That is why I have included the EHRC as a consultee as part of the Bill, because that should be taken into consideration as well. Many noble Lords made a range of reasonable suggestions for the proposals to be put forward in a public consultation, which I hope the Government are listening to, particularly the comments raised by the noble Lord, Lord Burns, given the commission that he led previously. We already have lots of good suggestions for what those proposals could be, but the thing is that this was in the Labour manifesto. We are waiting to see what the proposals are from the Government, because there is a mandate for it. I rebut the point that the public do not care about Lords reform. I know that a lot of noble Lords raised how they have gone into schools and universities to discuss what we do here and hear their views about what a future Parliament should look like. Actually, people are pretty engaged on the topic. If you ask them the questions, they will give you answers. So I dispute that point. A YouGov poll released last night shows yet again that only 12% of the public support the status quo, as in keeping the Chamber as it is. That is a clear mandate for us to get on with it and to respond to the public on what there is a mandate for. Finally, I must admit that I was thoroughly disappointed with the Minister’s response. The way that this Bill has been drafted is very much in line with what was written in the Labour manifesto. The intervention before the Minister sat down and her response to it show that perhaps there is not an intention to bring this forward before the next general election. In my view, when the public go to the polls and are voting on a manifesto that has been presented to them, that is what a political party is saying that they are going to deliver in that term. If there is not a consultation before the next general election, I do not see that the Government will have carried out their manifesto commitment. Unless there are proposals starting now to be investigated further, it would be very disappointing if, before the general election, that pledge had not even been started. I do not object to the idea that this House has a job to do, but I ask for transparency. The Government promised this consultation, and that is why I drafted the Bill this way, so it is unfortunate that they have made an argument against their own pledge. All I ask is that we have action. We need a timeline. The Bill I have presented is very modest in what it proposes: having a consultation and a timeline. It does not go as far as I would personally if I was in charge, but this is the manifesto that the Government were elected to deliver. On that note, I believe that we should trust the people and give them a say, finally, in relation to the future of the Parliament that represents them. I commend the Bill to the House. Bill read a second time and committed to a Committee of the Whole House.

More from Baroness Smith of Llanfaes (PC)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.