Contribution
My Lords, I am very pleased to support many of the amendments in this group, and I absolutely acknowledge that there is a difference between health inequalities and healthcare inequalities, but both need to be addressed. I shout out to my own GP practice, Chatfield Health Care, which is utterly brilliant and serves a very mixed economy. The noble Lord, Lord Patel, rightly said, in my view, that unless we address the issues pertaining to inequalities, then the healthy survival of the NHS is in question. Currently, I do not think that we are in a fit state to address the inequalities; this Bill is a golden opportunity to do that, and we absolutely must.
I go back to the Labour manifesto of 2024, which promised
“a fairer Britain, where everyone lives well for longer”.
It promised a shift to prevention and that Labour would halve the gap in HLE between richest and poorest regions through tackling the social determinants of health. This was followed up by the 10-year plan. Both of these have an excellent vision, but I fear that, too often, short-term pressures hinder long-term plans. I regret, for example, that the Mission Delivery Unit was disbanded and that long-term prevention no longer seems to be prioritised. That is why it is crucial that in this Bill we strengthen the duties on health inequalities.
I welcome the Government’s devolution agenda, about which we hear so much, including the English Devolution and Community Empowerment Act 2026 that we passed earlier this year, and the strong duty in that Act on strategic authorities to improve health and tackle health inequalities. The amendments before us today would place the equivalent duties on the Secretary of State for Health, with a requirement that Ministers across government have regard to them.
I agree that health inequalities should be addressed locally and that power being devolved to strategic authorities and local authorities will help enable those who are well placed to address the wider determinants. However, in a devolution-first world, the responsibilities and budgets of Whitehall departments mean that central government has a pivotal role and responsibility in addressing the many policies which have a profound impact on health that have been mentioned in this debate. Your Lordships supported and achieved parity of esteem for mental health, and the duty before us today would create a parity of esteem for prevention. It would be embedded as a shared goal across national, regional and local government. It is crucial.
The Government have made great progress in some areas, such as the smoke-free generation or ending the two-child limit. These changes will have a long-term benefit for health and reducing inequalities, but they do not represent a strategic across-government approach. In other areas, there have been good ambitions, such as a healthy food standard, but implementation has been slow and there have been loopholes. Such a patchy approach will not achieve health in all policies and will allow inequalities to keep widening. The approach must be across government.
As the noble Lord, Lord Patel, and my noble friend Lord Hunt said earlier, from 2000 to 2010 we made great progress thanks to that cross-government approach. Indeed, the Prime Minister was a part of that Government and in 2010 as Secretary of State he launched the Marmot review and subsequently made Greater Manchester the first Marmot city region. He has pledged to tackle regional inequality with good growth in every postcode, as we know, and to rewire the state in favour of prevention. We have heard many facts and figures today which demonstrate that this pledge must become a reality if our country is to fulfil its potential. I pay tribute in passing to Sir Michael Marmot, whose work is transformatory.
My noble friend might well speak of additional burdens, but she herself tabled amendments to the Health and Social Care Bill in 2022 requiring consultation and regular planning and reporting on the health and social care workforce. These amendments take a similar approach. They do not create a lot of processes. In fact, they codify what Ministers have already committed to but which is too often deprioritised. There are several precedents for creating accountability frameworks for cross-government agendas that are much more cumbersome, I would say, such as the Climate Change Act and the Child Poverty Act—not that they are not important; they certainly are.
My noble friend has certainly been in listening mode, and it is a pleasure to have interacted with her in so many meetings. I strongly urge her not just to listen to the arguments made this afternoon but to act and to amend the Bill so that we have a duty to address inequality and that it is done on a cross-departmental basis. It will make such a difference to the life and the health of the citizens of our country and consequently to the economics of our country.