T

The Minister of State, Department for Transport (Lord Hendy of Richmond Hill) (Lab)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 28 October 2026

Debate

Railways (Interoperability in Northern Ireland) (Convention on International Carriage by Rail) (Amendment) Regulations 2026

Contribution

My Lords, before I begin, I would like to convey heartfelt condolences on behalf of the United Kingdom Government to the families and friends of those who have lost their lives today in the tragic high-speed railway collision in Spain. Our sympathies are with all those who have been injured or affected by this terrible incident. The draft regulations, which were laid before the House on 29 June 2026, implement the UK’s obligations on rail interoperability under the Windsor Framework and update domestic legislation implementing the Convention concerning International Carriage by Rail, commonly known as COTIF. The regulations establish the conditions and technical requirements that railway vehicles, infrastructure and component products must satisfy before they can be placed on the market or put into service in Northern Ireland. Interoperability is about making sure that trains, railway infrastructure and railway equipment can operate safely and effectively across connected rail networks. The interoperability framework in Great Britain is set through the Railways (Interoperability) Regulations 2011. However, during the UK’s withdrawal from the European Union, EU states migrated to a new interoperability framework based on Directive 2016/797. Under the Windsor Framework, the United Kingdom is required to apply this directive in Northern Ireland in so far as it relates to the placing on the market, putting into service and free movement of railway products. The regulations implement that requirement by creating a dedicated interoperability framework for Northern Ireland. The framework established by the regulations facilitates interoperability between the Northern Irish and Irish railway networks while providing legal certainty for industry. The railways on the island of Ireland are functionally and technically distinct from Great Britain’s, with key differences including the track gauge of five feet and three inches in the whole of Ireland as opposed to four feet and eight and a half inches in Great Britain. The rail technical standards applicable in Britain and Northern Ireland have always reflected these inherent differences, even when the whole UK was applying EU interoperability law. There is, therefore, more practical benefit in Northern Ireland having closer interoperability with Ireland’s railways than with Great Britain’s. The Northern Ireland Minister for Infrastructure shares this view. The Minister wrote to me about the benefits of aligning with Ireland’s rail technical regime, which range beyond the operation of cross-border services. These include joint procurement of train fleets with Ireland and economies of scale for rail equipment, reducing procurement and operational costs. She said: “The more fundamental consideration is whether the conditions exist to support the long-term development of an integrated rail network across the island of Ireland. The standardised regulatory approach currently provided through the Windsor Framework creates an enabling environment for joint investment, shared procurement and coordinated railway operations. This is particularly important in the context of the recommendations emerging from the All-Island Strategic Rail Review, itself a key recommendation of the Union Connectivity Review”. Indeed, the joint procurement of the fleet of eight new trains for the Enterprise Service between Belfast and Dublin, due in 2030, a joint service between Northern Ireland and Irish Rail, was facilitated and made cheaper because there was only one technical regime between the two countries and one under which the successful supplier, which comes from the European Union, is familiar with. This legislation will therefore help the democratically elected Government in Northern Ireland to achieve their strategic policy aims in rail. I turn to the issues raised during parliamentary scrutiny. The Joint Committee on Statutory Instruments considered the regulations and did not draw them to the special attention of either House. The Secondary Legislation Scrutiny Committee raised several questions regarding implementation, consultation and the wider policy context, and I will address those matters now. The committee questioned the period between the UK’s obligation to implement these requirements, arising under the Windsor Framework, and the laying of these regulations. The UK had not implemented this directive before leaving the European Union. As a result, introducing these arrangements has required careful work to ensure that Northern Ireland and Great Britain can continue to operate effectively under their respective rail frameworks. Delivering these regulations required extensive technical and legal work; it required close engagement with the Department for Infrastructure and the European Union Agency for Railways to ensure the new arrangements would operate effectively. The regulations make changes in a range of technical areas, such as vehicle authorisation, which ultimately relate to rail interoperability and safety. The instrument is technical and legally complex, establishing a complete rail interoperability framework for Northern Ireland to implement the obligations under the Windsor Framework. Substantial implementation work was required to ensure that the regime could operate effectively in practice; this included developing Northern Ireland national technical rules, necessary to supplement the EU technical specifications. The regulations principally apply when introducing new equipment on the railway or making major changes to existing vehicles and infrastructure. The department is not aware of any such rail project being unable to proceed while this implementing legislation was in development, and the department took steps to ensure this through interim measures, including publishing technical notices specifying the EU rail interoperability requirements applicable in Northern Ireland. The Secondary Legislation Scrutiny Committee report questions the department’s understanding that legislation was needed. We have always been clear that legislation was needed and have been working at pace to get this right and in place as soon as practical. The department implemented interim administrative arrangements that allowed the new interoperability regime to operate in practice while the legislative framework was being finalised. We also informed the European Commission of this work while the implementation legislation was in preparation; therefore, many of the requirements in the directive already reflect practices and standards in operation in Northern Ireland. The committee also asked why updates relating to COTIF are being brought forward only now. The amendment reflects the UK’s position following EU exit. While the UK was a member of the European Union, this issue was addressed through the EU’s arrangements. Following EU exit, it became necessary to reflect the UK’s position directly in domestic legislation. The committee also questioned the decision not to undertake a formal public consultation. The Government carefully considered this issue. These regulations implement obligations that the UK has already entered into under the Windsor Framework and COTIF. There was therefore limited scope to take a different policy approach. While the policy outcome itself was constrained by existing international obligations, the department adopted a targeted engagement approach with those organisations most directly affected by the legislation, including the Department for Infrastructure, Translink, the Office of Rail and Road, the Rail Safety and Standards Board and conformity assessment bodies to inform a practical approach to the legislation. I subsequently also asked the UK industry trade body, the Railway Industry Association, whether its members had reported any adverse effects or expected any in future. They said they had no adverse comments from their members. I know that the noble Baroness, Lady Hoey, has tabled an amendment of regret relating to the absence of a formal consultation. While, of course, I respect those concerns, the Government’s view is that the targeted engagement undertaken was proportionate, given the nature of the regulations and the limited scope for alternative policy options. During scrutiny, concerns were raised regarding the existence of different regulatory arrangements in Northern Ireland and Great Britain, including in a submission from Mr Jim Allister MP. I recognise those concerns, but it is important to be clear about the purpose of these regulations. They do not create the United Kingdom’s obligations under the Windsor Framework, which are set out in the withdrawal agreement. These regulations are concerned with implementing these obligations and providing a clear and legally operable framework for industry and regulators. The department also continues to work closely with the Department for Infrastructure to understand and manage any future impacts arising from divergence between regulatory frameworks in Great Britain and Northern Ireland. I beg to move.

More from The Minister of State, Department for Transport (Lord Hendy of Richmond Hill) (Lab)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.