L

Lord McCrea of Magherafelt and Cookstown (DUP)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 28 October 2026

Debate

Railways (Interoperability in Northern Ireland) (Convention on International Carriage by Rail) (Amendment) Regulations 2026

Contribution

My Lords, it is important that we debate these regulations, because if they come into effect, they will end the existing arrangements that testify to the reality of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland, subject to a common legal framework in relation to railways. They cut our country in two, placing one part under a single regime and the other part under another. What is striking about this is that the law that is being applied to one part of the country through the regulations is not the legislation of a devolved legislature within the United Kingdom that reflects the wishes of the devolved legislators, who, in turn, reflect the wishes of their constituents. In actual fact, even if the whole Assembly unitedly opposed these, it would make no difference. That is the bottom line. The basic content has been devised by a foreign Parliament, in which the people of Northern Ireland are not represented. To some, that is acceptable, but to those who believe in the United Kingdom, it is not. This is an extraordinary humiliation of not only the people of Northern Ireland but the whole United Kingdom, which is, through this imposition, having its integrity disrespected by 27 states. We know that the doctrine of recognition in international relations means that diplomatic relations can be obtained between two or more sovereign states if they recognise each other’s territorial integrity on a reciprocal basis. However, through these regulations, the EU 27 not only refuse to recognise the territorial integrity of the United Kingdom by means of claiming a right to make the laws of the United Kingdom but they, in effect, make those laws and, in so doing, undermine the territorial integrity of the UK. This is in stark contradiction and violation of international law, which states that every state shall refrain from any action “aimed at the partial or total disruption of the national unity and territorial integrity of a State or country”— that is according to the declaration of the United Nations. These regulations testify to the efforts of 27 states to do the exact opposite: to disrupt the national unity and territorial integrity of the United Kingdom. To those who say that the regulations will ensure that the railways of the United Kingdom and Northern Ireland connect with those of the republic, implying that this is somehow providing a convincing argument, I remind them that while we in this country are more used to sea borders than land borders, most countries have rail borders with other countries, many of them on more than one front. However, even those that have only one rail border with another country do not find it a reason to subject itself to the laws of the neighbouring country. The United Kingdom and the Republic of Ireland should approach the question of how railway lines move from one country to another—as other sovereign states do—by means of agreement, not by dictating the laws in a foreign Parliament that the people of Northern Ireland have no representation in. The indignity has been greatly compounded by the decision of our Government not to hold a public consultation on this legislation, which runs through many provisions and is more like a Bill than a statutory instrument, albeit amendable. Of course, one can understand the logic. What is the point of having consultation? The United Kingdom will still have to bow in submission to the legislation set by parliamentarians elected to represent the constituents of other countries, not Northern Ireland. However, this only serves to underline the reality of our humiliation. Not only will the people of Northern Ireland be disfranchised; now they are not even worthy of consultation. Perhaps the Minister can explain whether the Government are content to allow divergence. When the legislation comes into force, the standards in Great Britain will be different from those in Northern Ireland. The supply to run our railways that previously came from GB will no longer be able to come unless GB suppliers are prepared to go through the problem of getting the EU declaration of conformity under regulations. There is a push to redirect our supply chain from the rest of the United Kingdom to the Irish Republic—and those who support the Windsor Framework would be quite happy with that.

More from Lord McCrea of Magherafelt and Cookstown (DUP)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.