Contribution
My Lords, I will speak to Amendments 62 and 69, which I have tabled in this group, and Amendment 78, to which I have added my name. The noble Lord, Lord Clement-Jones, is right to say that this is quite a disparate group. That just shows how complicated the issues in the Bill are and how fast moving this area is, as the Minister will know extremely well. I thank her for her engagement on these amendments and the conversations we have had.
Amendment 62 is about being guided not just by the size of a provider but by the risk that it presents. It reflects an amendment that was discussed in Committee. I moved it to Clause 29 at the suggestion of the Minister, because she pointed me to that clause. I had not spotted it, but Amendment 3 from the noble Lord, Lord Ravensdale, is perhaps another way of looking at this. I totally understand the point that he is making: SMEs need to know whether they are caught by this Bill and similar provisions in future. It may not be quite as easy as telling them whether they are in or out, but the issue—we are talking now about cyber security resilience—really has to be about the risk that these services pose to our essential or national infrastructure. As we saw just last week with the PHP attack, the reality is that it might be the smallest element of software that causes some of the greatest harm. I will return to these issues that Amendments 62 and 69 capture because I do not think that any Governments have yet worked out how to legislate on the basis of the risk posed by these services. It is exactly the same as the noble Lord, Lord Clement-Jones, said in the debate on the Online Safety Act about categorisation of platforms; it is an issue that is not going to go away and that we will return to later this week. The smallest platform or service can present the greatest risk. We have to work out a way to legislate or pass regulations that reflect this.
The regulations under Clauses 29 and 30 could bring in smaller providers, but the power is discretionary, there is no risk test and it comes with no commitment to use it. I am interested to hear the Minister’s response to that. The Government’s revised Part 4 extends national security directions to persons beyond regulated persons, regardless of size. Risk-based reach does therefore exist in the Bill, but only for national security and not for wider resilience risks.
Amendment 69 is about corporate governance, which might not seem the most exciting of subjects, but the Bill is about the regulation of essential activity. In Clause 24, “essential activity” is defined as activity
“essential to … the economy of the United Kingdom or … the day-to-day functioning of society”.
I do not think we can get much more essential than that. I think we will know about it if those activities and services are somehow massively undermined because of a lack of cyber resilience. This is an issue that I will return to. I do not necessarily intend to test the will of the House today on this, but I think it is now impossible for the culture of organisations to change or for senior-level accountability to exist—I have discussed this with both the noble Baroness and the AI Minister—without there being board-level accountability for the services being provided by the companies those boards are responsible for, and a clear understanding of the risks that those services might provide.
The noble Baroness suggested when we spoke that perhaps governance could be addressed in codes of practice. I am not sure that goes far enough, but it could be a start. Is a general duty of board oversight sufficient? I am very happy to discuss this further with both the noble Baroness and her ministerial colleagues. The Government have indicated that they think Clause 29 already allows regulators to address governance in codes of practice. They will not accept an individual fiduciary duty, but a general duty of board oversight may be acceptable. I would be interested to hear what the Government’s position is, but this is going to be relevant for all related tech or cyber resilience legislation.
On Amendment 78, to which I have added my name, I support the principle that large businesses should report on cyber security and resilience plans. I am not sure that it goes far enough, but I think it starts the point where boards and senior managers actually take responsibility for what their services are doing. It would be a welcome step forward, and that is why I was pleased to add my name. I look forward to hearing the Minister’s response on these issues, and I would very much welcome further conversations with her because these issues are not going to go away.