B

Baroness Lloyd of Effra (Lab)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 26 October 2026

Debate

Cyber Security and Resilience (Network and Information Systems) Bill

Contribution

I thank noble Lords for the constructive debate that we have had and heartily concur with the noble Lord, Lord Markham, on not only his happy returns to the noble Lord, Lord Clement-Jones, but the valuable contributions of noble Lords who have brought their expertise and experience to the wide variety of points that have been raised. These amendments all touch on a key point. The Bill’s potential will not be realised at Royal Assent but through effective implementation and clear measures of success. Let me begin with a key principle. The regulations must be durable and equip regulated entities to respond to any threat or hazard now and in the future. Neither the Bill nor its implementation should narrowly focus on specific technologies or risks. These will soon become outdated, so that would undercut a holistic approach to risk. Through the security and resilience requirements, or SRRs, we will take this purposeful “all technologies, all threats, all hazards” approach to protecting regulated services. As I have set out, these requirements will be introduced in secondary legislation and will be mandatory. We propose that they will cover, among other topics, data security, risk management, board governance and incident response and recovery. We will be consulting on SRR proposals in the coming months. I thank noble Lords who attended the round table that I hosted on them after Grand Committee. As such, I caution against singling out specific risks such as data poisoning, as highlighted by the noble Lord, Lord Holmes, as they do not reflect the full range of risks that each entity manages. The noble Lord raised incident reporting. This is already designed to capture incidents that have a significant impact on the authenticity and integrity of data, so that is already within the scope of the reporting framework. The SRRs will further touch on a number of topics raised by noble Lords, which I will address in turn. On data retention, UK GDPR requires public organisations to implement appropriate measures to ensure the security of personal data. The Information Commission regulates the data protection legislation independently of government. Under the existing NIS framework, service operators can and do assess their data retention. For example, the health sector assesses compliance against a tailored cyber assessment framework objective on using and sharing information appropriately. This includes principles on transparency, using and sharing information and records management. However, as a result of the focus on this that noble Lords have brought—in particular the noble Lord, Lord Markham—I will ensure that the SRR proposals in the upcoming consultation cover data underpinning the provision of regulated services and include minimising unnecessary data collection and retention.

More from Baroness Lloyd of Effra (Lab)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.