L

Lord Alton of Liverpool (CB)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 26 October 2026

Debate

Cyber Security and Resilience (Network and Information Systems) Bill

Contribution

My Lords, as I indicated earlier in our proceedings, I want to speak to government Amendment 45. In doing so, I reiterate my thanks to the noble Baroness, Lady Lloyd of Effra, for the diligent way in which she has engaged with those who were concerned about data sharing with hostile states. This amendment had its origins in another place, where Sir Iain Duncan Smith moved an amendment concerned that data might be shared with countries that do not have a judicial system that would ensure that, for instance, extradition requests would stand up to scrutiny. Particular examples were given of things like the national security law in Hong Kong and how data might be shared that would allow young people who have been involved in pro-democracy protests there to then be removed from the United Kingdom and have to stand trial in a place such as Hong Kong. During our proceedings in the Joint Committee on Human Rights, which I referred to earlier, we had a remarkable young woman who waived her anonymity to come and give evidence to us. Chloe Cheung was just a young teenager when she took part in pro-democracy demonstrations in Hong Kong. She, like many others under our BNO scheme, came to live and claim sanctuary in the UK. At the age of 19, she was told that a bounty of 1 million Hong Kong dollars would be placed on her head. She was not alone; there were several others, including Carmen Lau, who was a legislator in the Hong Kong legislature. One of their great fears in giving evidence to our committee was that they would be subjected to all sorts of intimidation in the UK, including potential removal in due course. They had seen the incident that had occurred outside the PRC consulate in Manchester and were fearful about the new super-embassy being created in London, and all of us on that committee unanimously signed a report saying that we had to go a lot further in dealing with transnational repression. Having had its origins in the House of Commons, the amendment was supported by a number of organisations across the non-governmental organisation sector. In particular, I pay tribute to the work of the Inter-Parliamentary Alliance on China and, notably, Luke de Pulford and Jaya Pathak, who participated in the constructive and helpful meetings that we held with the Minister. Here in the House of Lords, the amendment was recast and retabled by me with the noble Lords, Lord Hunt of Kings Heath and Lord Markham, and the noble Baroness, Lady Ludford. In my unavoidable absence at that moment in the Committee, I was extremely grateful to each of them for their important remarks and support. That unity of purpose has resulted in a shared, unyielding conviction that, in an era of unprecedented systematic competition, our sensitive regulatory and enforcement data must never, in any circumstances, be exposed or gifted to hostile authoritarian regimes. In the best traditions of your Lordships’ House, the noble Baroness carefully listened to the grave concerns which were raised and recognised the fatal vulnerability in the Bill as originally drafted. She has acted decisively. By closing the loophole that would have permitted disclosure to authorities in any foreign country with a strict, closed list of trusted democratic partners—our Five Eyes allies and our friends across the EEA and Switzerland—the Government have closed a dangerous statutory void. For that constructive engagement and for bringing forward these amendments, I am profoundly grateful. I refer again to the brave dissidents and diaspora striving to live in peace on our shores, despite intimidation from regimes such as the CCP, and what the noble Lord, Lord Robertson, memorably described as the “deadly quartet” of China, Russia, North Korea and Iran. It is outrageous that people resident in the UK have been subjected to intimidation, harassment and coercion as political targets, some of it utilising data and cyber availability, in CCP-orchestrated extensive and sophisticated campaigns of transnational repression. Hostile states routinely camouflage political persecution as legitimate, with the systemic abuse, as we heard in the Joint Committee on Human Rights, of Interpol red notices, for instance. Network and information systems data, such as IP addresses, server logs and digital fingerprints, are not neutral administrative information. In the hands of hostile states and their security services, that can become actionable intelligence used to unmask, to geolocate and to surveil individuals on British soil. We desperately need a comprehensive cross-departmental strategy to prohibit such actions, and government Amendment 45 is a step in that direction. For that, I am extremely grateful to the noble Baroness and felt no need therefore to bring back an amendment in any hostile way today.

More from Lord Alton of Liverpool (CB)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.