B

Baroness Harding of Winscombe (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 26 October 2026

Debate

Cyber Security and Resilience (Network and Information Systems) Bill

Contribution

My Lords, there are a lot of amendments in this group that attempt to fill the AI-shaped hole in the Bill. I probably speak for everyone who engaged in Committee when I say that we were all intensely frustrated by the absence of AI in the Bill. It is in danger of proving correct the people who think that you cannot regulate AI, because we are not even trying. This is quite a complex group. I extend my support to Amendment 65 in the name of the noble Lord, Lord Clement-Jones, on “last-resort” powers; Amendment 66 in the name of the noble Lord, Lord Tarassenko, on AISI audit powers; and Amendment 67 in the name of the noble Baroness, Lady Kidron, on AI red lines. I will not speak to them, because I know that everyone wants to move at pace. I will focus my remarks only on Amendment 41. My amendment is not techy or complex; it is very simple. It would require frontier labs to report to essential services and their relevant regulator if one of their AI agents or models gained unauthorised access to UK essential services and/or their data. The reporting requirements would be similar to those imposed on the essential services—the 24/72-hour piece that we have just been discussing. By way of example, if a frontier lab’s AI agent accessed NHS data without permission, once the frontier lab became aware of this, it would be required to report the incident within 24 hours, update within 72 hours and issue a final report within 14 days. This is currently not happening, as witnessed in Australia quite recently. OpenAI accessed Australian Medicare data in June. It did not inform the Australian Government until September via an unmanned email address, such that the Australian Prime Minister was at the UN General Assembly rallying support for the innovative growth potential of AI while OpenAI knew that it had accessed his country’s health data and he did not. Other countries are already requiring this basic thing. In New York, the RAISE Act requires AI frontier labs to report within 72 hours if one of their agents has gone rogue. In California, it is within 52 hours. The EU AI Act requires it without undue delay. The AI labs themselves agree that clear reporting requirements would be helpful. In front of the Business, Innovation, Science and Trade Committee in the other place only last week, representatives of OpenAI and Anthropic, including my noble friend Lord Booth-Smith, representing Anthropic, supported the idea of required reporting, at least in principle—that is an important “at least”, I suspect. I know there is concern that this could be seen as international overreach and that all AI regulation needs to be global. That is one of the favourite tropes of tech companies: “Do not do anything locally; it has to be done globally”. Those of us who have campaigned for regulation of social media have been fighting that battle for more than a decade. But this really is an instance that does not need to be global. This is about UK services and data being illegally accessed. It does not matter that it might be an American company doing the accessing—it is accessing our data illegally. This surely should be the purview of this House. I believe the Minister agrees with me. I think the Government’s AI Minister in the other place also agrees with me. In fact, he has said in public that it is important to have these reporting requirements. However, I cannot see it in this Bill. I support government Amendment 70 in this group, but that just puts even stronger requirements on the essential services that might have had their data hacked, not on the companies whose AI agents would have done the hacking. I very much hope that the Minister can explain to me and all of us in this House how the Government intend to require AI labs to report incidents and when this is likely to come into effect, if not through this amendment. It is simple common sense that if these agents access our data, they should be under a legal obligation to tell us. We should not be leaving that to chance; we should be making it the law. I beg to move.

More from Baroness Harding of Winscombe (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.