L

Lord Birt (CB)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 26 October 2026

Debate

Cyber Security and Resilience (Network and Information Systems) Bill

Contribution

Amendment 163 is in my name and those of the noble Lords, Lord Markham and Lord Clement-Jones, and the noble Baroness, Lady Kidron. I think the earlier stages of this Bill have seen this House on all sides at its very best, with Members bringing real-life experience and serious expertise to bear in a considered and non-partisan way on the grievous challenge that the cyber threat presents to our country. That scrutiny has demonstrated, I am afraid, just how limited this Bill is in addressing that grievous challenge. It has almost been forgotten in our debate today that it focuses on only a small fraction of the economy and the public sector, not on the lessons of JLR, M&S, TfL or the Department for Education. It fails to appreciate the enormous complexity of technology platforms and the origin of their vulnerabilities. Just a few days ago, a leading CTO, in the midst of negotiating a contract to be supplied with data services by a leading provider, read out to me one of the legal conditions of that supply: “We shall not be responsible for any damage caused to the customer’s computer or to customer data, or for any bugs, viruses, Trojan horses or other destructive code”. Extraordinarily, and this has been touched on more than once today, the draft of the Bill that reached us did not even mention AI. Can that be believed? It is a Bill that creates a multiplicity of cyber regulators, an estimated 18 in all. In Northern Ireland it is the Department of Finance that will be the designated regulator, not just for energy but for health, road and rail and drinking water. How could 18 regulators possibly amass the necessary skills to regulate in this deeply complex and ever-evolving environment? Week by week, as we have considered the Bill, the ever-darkening cyber storm-clouds gather. Last week, as we all will have noticed, the PHP incident affected 70% of the world wide web, with 10 million servers identified as at risk. Our amendment seeks to see the Bill as a work in progress. It would require the Government, over the coming 12 months, to address the whole of the challenge identified throughout our proceedings and to conduct and publish a review, inter alia, of the appropriate regulatory framework for cyber, which we manifestly do not have; a review of which organisations have a material impact on the economy and society in both the public and private sectors and should be brought into scope; a review of what obligations should be placed on those organisations to promote cyber resilience; a review of what obligations to provide safe services should be placed on technology suppliers, and noble Lords should remember the quote I have just read out; a review of what scale and nature of cyber professionalism the UK needs; a review of what incidents should be reported and to whom; and, critically, a review of the powers of the AI Security Institute or another regulator in relation to frontier AI systems—a matter that has come up over and over again today—to make AI a safe technology for us all to deploy. Our hope is that this Minister will welcome the opportunity that such a review would present to address all the many questions that have arisen but not been properly answered today, and that it would speedily promote further legislation that would enable us to grip this challenge in a way that the Bill in its present form simply does not.

More from Lord Birt (CB)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.