L

Lord Palmer of Childs Hill (LD)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 29 October 2026

Debate

Personal Independence Payment and Disability Benefits: Implementation and Impact

Contribution

My Lords, I thank the noble Baroness, Lady Jenkin, for setting this debate in process. I trust the Government will listen to the interesting comments that are being made. I welcome the new Front Bench team and wish them well. I begin with a practical question about whether the benefits system responds when people tell it that their circumstances have changed. I recently raised with another Minister, the noble Baroness, Lady Sherlock, the case of someone receiving sickness benefits; he had reported that he had recovered but was still waiting for a reassessment four years later. I was not asking the noble Baroness then—and I am not now asking the Minister now—to discuss an individual’s personal circumstances; I am asking about the administration of the system. Can the Minister say how common delays of this kind are? How many people who have reported an improvement in their condition are still awaiting reassessment? How long have they been waiting, and what has been done to put it right? If someone tells the department that their circumstances have changed, surely they should be able to expect a timely response. This is not a question about an individual; it is a question about how the department operates. However, let me be equally clear about what I am not arguing. I am not calling for everyone to face more frequent assessments. We need fewer unnecessary reassessments, particularly for people with lifelong or degenerative conditions. Repeatedly asking someone to demonstrate needs that have not changed serves neither the claimant nor the taxpayer. We need to distinguish between reassessments that serve a purpose and those that simply repeat, again and again, what is already known. Reducing unnecessary reassessments and responding promptly to reported changes are not contradictory objectives; they are two elements of competent administration. Turning specifically to PIP, we must distinguish between failures in the way the benefit operates and the value of the support it provides. PIP helps people meet the extra costs of disability. It is not an out-of-work benefit. People can receive it while working, and becoming able to work does not in itself mean that they no longer qualify. That distinction matters; otherwise, we risk discussing disability benefits as though everybody receiving them is in the same position, with the same needs and the same prospects. They are not. For many people, PIP is a lifeline, not a luxury. Its purpose is to support independence and participation, helping disabled people exercise choices that others can take for granted. Payment in cash is an important strength of the system. By that I mean giving people control over how the money is spent. Disabled people should be able to decide how best to meet their own needs rather than having those decisions made arbitrarily for them. An extra journey, help with a daily task or a different way of managing life at home may seem a small matter to someone else; to the individual concerned, it may make the difference between dependence and independence. The freedom should be protected in any reform—I hope that the department will think about that. We must also take care with the language of this debate. Rising claimant numbers deserve scrutiny. Ministers must explain expenditure, account for decisions and demonstrate that public money is being used properly. However, a debate dominated by numbers risks losing sight of the people behind them. We should not allow legitimate questions about administration and affordability—both of which I have made—to become a general suspicion of people who need support. Nor should we make someone feel that applying for help is an admission of failure. A fair system must command public confidence, but it must also command the confidence of those who depend upon it. That brings me to the assessment process. In our 2024 manifesto, the Liberal Democrats called for greater transparency in PIP assessments and an end to unnecessary reassessments. Those remain important objectives, but transparency alone is not enough. We need decisions that are better informed, more accurate and easier to understand. Assessors need the training and time to understand how conditions interact. They must be able to recognise that the effects of disability and ill health can fluctuate. An assessment should not reduce someone’s life to how they appear during a single appointment. Some may manage a task on one occasion but struggle to repeat it. They may present confidently while finding daily life extremely difficult. The question should be about what someone can manage in practice, not simply what an assessor sees, often in a brief encounter. Supporting evidence must be properly considered, and decisions must explain clearly how that evidence has been weighed. When a decision is wrong, individuals should not have to become an expert in the benefits system to challenge it. Getting decisions right first time should be a central measure of success, not an aspiration left at the margins of reform. We must also recognise the limits of what benefits reform alone can achieve. Changing an assessment process cannot substitute for timely NHS treatment. It cannot by itself make a workplace accessible or ensure that appropriate employment support is available. If the Government want more disabled people who can work to either remain in or enter employment, they must address those practical barriers, along with the benefits system. Disabled people must have a meaningful role throughout the reform process, not simply be invited to comment after the principal decisions have been made. Their experience should help shape the questions asked, the evidence considered and the way success is measured. I ask the Minister for three assurances. The first is that unnecessary reassessments will be reduced while reported changes in circumstances are dealt with properly, and that the Government will provide information enabling us to judge progress. The second is that the assessor training and the use of supporting evidence will improve, with a clear focus on getting decisions right first time. The third is that disabled people will help design and evaluate reform, with their independence and dignity treated as essential tests of success. Lastly, after those three items, we must not forget the person who asked for a reassessment and was not given it. Is that a one-off? We should not have to choose between compassion and competent administration. A properly functioning system must provide both. It should support people when they need help, respond when their circumstances change and explain its decisions clearly. That is how we build trust, not through repeated promises of reform but through a system that works fairly, accurately and with respect for the people it serves. Many points were made during this debate. That is not against PIP; it shows the value of PIP and how it needs to be administered.

More from Lord Palmer of Childs Hill (LD)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.