L

Lord Garnier (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 3 November 2026

Debate

Prison (Governor’s and Adjudicators’ Punishments) (Amendment) Rules 2026

Contribution

My Lords, the Government advanced two inconsistent reasons for the statutory instrument. First, they say that the incidence of violence and rule-breaking in prisons is going up, and therefore governors and independent adjudicators need harsher or stricter options available to punish the serious and repeat rule-breaking. Secondly, they say that, because the Sentencing Act 2026 reduced the amount of time that prisoners will serve on their sentence, governors need to have the ability to keep them in. It strikes me as odd and sad that the central question asked by the noble and learned Lord, Lord Thomas, has not been thought about by the Government: has anybody asked themselves why prisoners commit acts of indiscipline or break the rules in the first place? It is largely because they are incarcerated for 23 out of 24 hours a day, in a multi-occupied cell, they essentially live in a public lavatory, and they are largely mentally ill, illiterate and innumerate. The Minister used to work in Holloway prison, so she will know that everyone who spoke this evening, apart from the noble Baroness, Lady Gill, said some quite sensible things. If you keep people in those conditions and fail to give them a sense of purpose and to rehabilitate them, you not only let them down, and endanger the lives and working conditions of the governors and the prison staff, but you waste taxpayer money and do not provide us with the requisite safety that we require of a rehabilitated prisoner—because they come back just as they went in, and so they reoffend. I ask the Government to be a little more intelligent and think a little more strategically about this, and not to resort to the usual government rubbish of reacting in a knee-jerk way without having applied their minds to the problem in front of them. It is not surprising that, when prison governors and other prison group directors were asked about these measures, they were hesitant and sceptical. If the Minister believes that this will be a good idea, when the professionals in the business clearly think it will not, she needs to have another think. I will not complain about the English of the Explanatory Notes, but when the Government say: “Engagement with internal stakeholders to explore the impact on external policy areas, such as prisoner family and relations, trade unions, and third sector stakeholders, has commenced and will continue to occur prior to this instrument coming into force”, I ask myself, first, what on earth that means, secondly, has it happened, and, thirdly, when will we hear about the result. Please do not allow this House to be fooled into thinking that this is a good idea; it plainly is not.

More from Lord Garnier (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.