L

Lord Foster of Bath (LD)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 3 November 2026

Debate

Prison (Governor’s and Adjudicators’ Punishments) (Amendment) Rules 2026

Contribution

My Lords, on these Benches, we support the broad thrust of the Government’s proposals, but, like many others, we are concerned by the proposal to withdraw family visits as a punishment in the cases covered by the SI. That is why we support the regret Motion in the name of the noble Lord, Lord Farmer. Few have done more than he has to demonstrate the importance of family relationships in reducing reoffending and helping prisoners rebuild their lives. I chair your Lordships’ Justice and Home Affairs Select Committee. In our report on prisons last year, we argued that the prisoners’ punishment is the loss of liberty, and that the job of prisons is to reduce reoffending through education, purposeful activity, tackling addiction and mental health problems, and preparing people for release. That also means, as so many people have said, maintaining family relationships. As the noble Lord, Lord Farmer, has rightly described, family ties are the golden thread in reducing reoffending. Evidence shows that family contact improves prison behaviour, supports mental health, reduces self-harm and, importantly, reduces reoffending. Against that backdrop, I find it extraordinary that the Government should introduce rules allowing family visits to be withdrawn as a disciplinary punishment. Of course, effective sanctions are needed, but why introduce a punishment which undermines the very thing that makes prisons and the public safer? There are three fundamental objections. First, as the noble Baroness, Lady Fox, said, it is counterproductive. Family contact provides hope, emotional stability and an incentive to behave responsibly; removing it risks increasing isolation, frustration and resentment. Secondly, as the noble and learned Lord, Lord Stewart, said, it punishes innocent people. Partners, parents, adult children and other relatives have committed no offence, yet lose contact with someone they love. The exemption for children under 18 is, of course, welcome, but what about everybody else? Thirdly, as the noble Baroness, Lady Wheatcroft, said, it damages relationships essential for successful resettlement. Families often provide accommodation, practical help and emotional support on release. Why weaken those relationships? Disciplinary sanctions may be necessary, but they should address a prisoner’s behaviour without damaging relationships that will help to prevent future crime. We should strengthen relationships that help prisoners to turn their lives around, not take them away. The consequences will be felt by prisoners, innocent families and, ultimately, by the communities to which prisoners return. If we are serious about fewer victims, safer communities and less crime, we must stop treating family contact as a privilege that can be withdrawn and instead recognise it as essential to reducing reoffending and protecting the public. I hope that the Government will think again.

More from Lord Foster of Bath (LD)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.