B

Baroness Hayter of Kentish Town (Lab)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 3 November 2026

Debate

Time is Money: How Regulators Can Support Growth (Industry and Regulators Committee Report)

Contribution

I will try to do this briefly, as I can see that team B is just arriving. I thank all the speakers, and I especially thank the Minister for that reply. She ought to take great comfort from how much agreement there was across the Room—although I know that no Liberal Democrats spoke. There has been a very strong commonality in our responses, particularly on the idea that regulation cannot create growth. The comment from the noble Lord, Lord Udny-Lister, about infrastructure pointed to where that could be of advantage more broadly. I am afraid I have been exchanging texts with the staff, and they think that it was the noble Lord who came up with the title, Time is Money. Can we congratulate him on that? I will not try to repeat everything, except to say three things; I apologise for having said them before. One is that there was commonality around the need for regulators to be able to respond rapidly to innovation and to provide the pace, clarity, certainty and predictability that business needs. The noble Lord, Lord Ashcombe, used the phrase “intelligent regulation”, which may encompass it, but I think that it was the noble Baroness, Lady Harding, who said that all this has to be in the interest of British business and the British public. That is really the core of what we want to do. There are three points to take away. As my noble friends Lord Chandos and Lord Sikka said, we must not lose sight of the need to protect consumers. These regulations did not grow. We do not have statutory regulation by accident; it is there for a purpose, and we need to continue to protect that. Secondly, we need political cover if we are going to ask regulators to become a little more chancy and to meet the challenge that we and the Government have sent their way. We also need to recognise the costs of poor regulation. It will fall to the Government to enable regulators to respond to new technology, but there are certain things that only the Government can do—the single front door, for example. No one regulator can do that or, in the words of my noble friend Lady Gill, deal with legacy rules. That falls to the Government, not to individual regulators. The other challenge is that the existing growth duty—it is not new—has done very little to change regulators’ risk appetites, because it added another duty. They are going to have to make trade-offs. The Government must respond to that and think about how to change the conflicting demands of their core responsibilities and this, as well as about how to balance these new demands. There are, therefore, things for the Government to do that individual regulators cannot do. Perhaps we can invite my noble friend the Minister to come to our committee when the Bill is published—I hope that the members of my committee will agree to this—to discuss how we can move forward. With that, I thank everybody for their contributions and I commend this report to the Committee.

More from Baroness Hayter of Kentish Town (Lab)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.