Contribution
My Lords, my Amendment 43 seeks to ensure that the extension of votes to 16 year-olds, as argued by the noble Lord, Lord Wallace of Saltaire, is accompanied by the necessary citizenship education to prepare young people to exercise their new rights and responsibilities as citizens. A number of noble Lords emphasised this in the debates about 16 and 17 year-olds on our first day in Committee. The amendment calls for a catch-up programme of political and media literacy and citizenship, supported by teacher training, with particular attention to the needs of student groups who face socioeconomic disadvantage or most lack electoral confidence, including girls and young women.
I should say that the noble Baroness, Lady Bennett of Manor Castle, who supports my amendment, asked me to give her apologies that she cannot be in her place to speak to her Amendment 44, which would place responsibility for citizenship education on the Electoral Commission; otherwise, it is very similar in its tone to my amendment.
I applaud the extension of the franchise to 16 and 17 year-olds, but I am well aware, from research that I was involved in as an academic some years ago, that some young people, not surprisingly, lack confidence about voting. Professor Bryony Hoskins of the University of Roehampton—who has conducted more recent research and whose assistance I am grateful for—tells me that
“young people approach their first election with unequal access to political learning, unequal confidence and different opportunities to practise making their voices heard. Without action to address these differences, there is a risk that the reform will disproportionately benefit those already equipped to participate”.
This underlines the importance of good citizenship education. I was a member of the Select Committee on Citizenship and Civic Engagement, the spirit of which lived on in the recent QSD in the name of the noble Lord, Lord Norton of Louth. The committee emphasised:
“Citizenship education has a crucial role to play in helping to build active citizens”.
Its importance is all the greater in the context of the extension of the franchise to 16 and 17 year-olds.
More recently, the APPG on Political and Media Literacy—supported by Shout Out UK, to which I am also grateful for its help—has pointed to
“a growing body of research indicating that young people who receive structured political and media education demonstrate higher levels of civic engagement and greater resilience to misinformation”.
They are more likely to become first-time voters, which increases the chances of them voting subsequently.
With regard to gender, Professor Hoskins’s research shows that even though girls tend to outperform boys in civic knowledge, they demonstrate lower confidence in their ability to understand and engage in formal politics. Longitudinal research in England shows that the gender gap in political confidence widens between ages 11 and 16, precisely the years preceding the proposed voting age.
When it comes to socioeconomic disadvantage, the IP-PAD UK adolescent study found that civic confidence diverges sharply by place. Its report suggested that
“'democratic confidence is shaped not only by age, but also by socio-economic experience”.
Another study, by Dr James Weinberg at the University of Sheffield, underlined the current fragmented state of democratic education in England, with stark disparities between private schools and state schools serving affluent communities on the one hand and state schools in economically deprived communities on the other. More affluent parents are more likely to talk to their children about politics and to feel confident doing so. It is perhaps not surprising that other research found that, when they had access to it, disadvantaged students often gained more from citizenship education than their more privileged peers.
Research undertaken by Professor Hoskins for G-EPIC—Gender Empowerment through Politics in Classrooms—has developed and evaluated teaching approaches designed to strengthen political confidence, particularly among more disadvantaged girls. Its research should inform the kind of catch-up programme envisaged in this amendment. Indeed, ACT—the Association for Citizenship Teaching, which has done so much to press the cause of citizenship education—is currently promoting these teaching resources.
I welcome the Government’s appreciation of the importance of citizenship education, especially to newly enfranchised voters, as expressed, for example, by my noble friend Lady Smith of Malvern in winding up the recent QSD.
I have a number of questions for my noble friend the Minister. First, how will the Government ensure that newly enfranchised young people receive appropriate citizenship education before their first opportunity to vote? Secondly, how will that provision address the gender and socioeconomic inequalities in political confidence that I have raised? Thirdly, what teacher training and resources will support inclusive delivery? Fourthly, how will implementation be evaluated to establish its success in benefiting young people facing the greatest barriers to political participation?
In concluding, I stress the urgency of the kind of catch-up programme envisaged in this amendment. In its briefing on the Bill, the Electoral Commission notes:
“We’ve long recommended improvements to democratic education in schools, and the lowering of the voting age makes this more pressing”.
As my noble friend Lady Smith of Malvern said at the end of the QSD:
“This is a pivotal moment for citizenship education”.—[Official Report, 19/10/26; col. 545.]
The need to act quickly was emphasised by my noble friend Lord Blunkett, the honorary president of ACT, who regrets he cannot be in its place. He warned that, if we fail to revise the curriculum so as to inform, educate and equip young people to take on voting at the ages of 16 and 17, it will be a dereliction of duty. Can my noble friend the Minister reassure us that we will fulfil our duty to the young people who will exercise their rights and responsibilities as citizens for the first time—I hope—at the next general election?