Contribution
I will start where the noble Lord left off. I am grateful to all noble Lords who have contributed to this debate. The amendments in this group raise many important questions about the responsibilities that accompany the Government’s proposal to lower the voting age to 16. It is a manifesto commitment, we accept that, but there are responsibilities that go alongside that and things the Government need to be aware of and address, because there is no doubt that people out there will be asking about this.
We should all agree that young people ought to understand how our democracy works, how to register to vote and how to exercise their democratic rights, but we must consider whether the Government have put sufficient thought into the education and safeguards necessary if the change to the franchise is to go ahead. My noble friend Lord Fuller’s Amendments 18 and 19 would sensibly require politically neutral and balanced voter registration to be provided to young people. These amendments seek to prevent local authorities run by any particular party from influencing election material one way or the other. We must not forget that councils are fundamentally political organisations.
My noble friend Lord Fuller has accurately identified that looked-after children are socially vulnerable and at risk of being influenced by the authority that looks after them. We should be aware of that fundamental point. Information provided by public authorities must be impartial, especially when it concerns young people who may be engaging with the electoral system for the very first time. Can the Minister explain what safeguards will ensure that registration information provided by local authorities, and the relevant bodies in Northern Ireland, is politically neutral? How will be compliance be assessed and monitored?
I welcome my noble friend Lord Farmer’s Amendments 24, 280 and 287, concerning the decision-making abilities of 16 and 17 year-olds. I congratulate my noble friend Lady Meyer on putting the case for considering the safeguards around that as well. These amendments ask the Government to assess the evidence before implementing a significant constitutional change. They are not saying that that change is not going to happen but that they should consider it beforehand. Can the Minister explain what assessment the Government have undertaken of the decision-making abilities of 16 and 17 year-olds, and will she commit to publishing that evidence before the new voting age comes into effect?
The amendments concerning citizenship education and political literacy are also relevant. Amendment 43, in the name of the noble Baroness, Lady Lister, proposes a programme of education and citizenship in secondary schools. The noble Lord, Lord Wallace of Saltaire, has also raised that the Secretary of State should report on progress in the changes to citizenship education. Thus, there is clearly a shared recognition across your Lordships’ House that extending the franchise cannot be considered in isolation from the education that young people receive—everyone is in agreement on that one.
However, I must respectfully disagree with Amendment 44, tabled by the noble Baroness, Lady Bennett, albeit that it was not spoken to. While I welcome the underlying suggestion that children should be educated about their duty to vote, we should not single out groups of children and educate them based on supposed groupings. Different children must not be educated differently about the vote they share. As we saw in the fruitful debate on ballot secrecy, we must be careful that political education does not become political persuasion. Can the Minister tell us what guidance will be provided to schools and teachers to ensure that such education remains balanced, and what additional resources will be made available to deliver it?
My noble friend Lady Berridge is, unfortunately, unable to be in her place today. My noble friend Lord Leigh of Hurley referred to her Amendment 44A, in which she raises a very valid point. I think most of us in this Chamber have canvassed and knocked on doors. When we see a young person, we generally say, “Can we speak to Mum and Dad, or your carer?” We will now have to assess what age that young person is and maybe engage in conversation with them. We really need to consider that as a consequence of this proposal as canvassers will be engaging with younger voters.
My noble friend raises whether there will need to be necessary safeguarding guidance for political campaigners engaging with children. We should be thinking about that particularly important issue. If political parties and campaigners are to engage more directly with younger voters, appropriate safeguards must be in place. Will the Minister explain what guidance will govern contact between political campaigners and those children, and whether the Government intend to consult safeguarding professionals before the relevant provisions commence?
As I have said in earlier debates, electoral reform should strengthen public confidence in our democratic system, not introduce uncertainty about the protections on which it depends. The Government have chosen to lower the voting age as a manifesto commitment. It is therefore incumbent upon them to demonstrate that young people will receive impartial information, sufficient education and appropriate safeguarding. They should be properly prepared and protected when exercising that right. I hope the Minister will address these questions in detail and provide reassurance that the practical consequences of this change have been fully and properly considered.