B

Baroness Coffey (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 9 November 2026

Debate

Health Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I am interested in the amendments tabled by the noble Lord, Lord Scriven, particularly Amendment 40, but I will speak to them in a slightly different way. What I am trying to understand is how his amendment differs from the current NHS constitution—it is reviewed every 10 years on a statutory basis; it happened only fairly recently—and the targets associated with patients’ constitutional rights. How would this work with the outcomes for the health service and integrated care boards? I am actually very supportive of the change the Government are seeking to introduce. That partly comes from experience of trying to pull a few levers: sometimes the levers work, but other times you need to get on with things. A good example of how this could be deployed is if a Prime Minister decides that, instead of how IVF treatment happens now, there will be a postcode lottery around the country. At the moment, I think you are guaranteed just one. If they decided that everybody should have three, by issuing a direction and—importantly, given the clause—putting in the money to go with it, they could straightforwardly make a transformational change across the NHS. That would be instead of the Lansley Act approach, which is to work from the bottom up and evolve over time. This brings us back full circle: understandably, the public think that politicians are generally in charge and if they stand on a manifesto commitment, they should be able to deliver it. This measure is welcome in that regard. I do not think that this will be used to stop the closure of a particular hospital, but—dare I say it—if it is, so what? That would be acceptable so long as the Government come up with the cash to keep that hospital or maternity care unit open. Very soon, there will be only one maternity unit in the whole of the county of Norfolk, and that is a big area to cover. Perhaps that is because there are fewer births, but it is nevertheless worrying, given that it is necessary to travel for well over an hour to get to a hospital to give birth. If the Government decide that this is not appropriate, instead of going through this rather complex ICB consultation, it would be much easier if the Secretary of State could say that they are not prepared for that to happen and are prepared to achieve something else—whatever the situation is. I am just giving examples because I think we were asked what kinds of examples this could be used for.

More from Baroness Coffey (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.