Contribution
My Lords, in responding to this group, I will endeavour to set out how we expect the Secretary of State to act and our overall approach to this topic. I am doing that because I hope it will be helpful not just in this group but in the next one, which relates also to the power of direction. I appreciate the understanding of my noble friend Lord Hunt and the noble Baroness, Lady Coffey, in seeing the practical way that the Bill is seeking to work—in the round, I might add. That is what has struck me about this valid debate to unpick what the Bill will do.
With permission, I will address all the amendments in relation to Clauses 8, 11 and 21 together in this group. On Amendment 47, tabled in the name of the noble Lord, Lord Patel, I can confirm that the Secretary of State will continue to routinely obtain appropriate advice to inform all decision-making, and they will have access to a wide range of clinical, scientific and public health expertise. That will ensure that decisions are informed by professional and clinical insight—for example, from the Chief Medical Officer, the Chief Nursing Officer, standing expert committees and ad hoc advice. To further strengthen clinical leadership across the system and advice given to Ministers on the NHS’s major clinical priorities in the health and care system, which is a matter that has come up a number of times, we will establish the first clinical council. This will bring together a small group of senior clinicians to strengthen leadership, and their experience of treating patients and improving services will directly inform our decision-making in those areas.
Before moving on, I want to briefly mention Amendments 30 and 31, tabled by the noble Lord, Lord Scriven, which reference Clause 8 of this Bill. The power in this clause is distinct from the general power of direction in Clause 11, and allows the Secretary of State to direct integrated care boards to exercise functions on their behalf. While the ICB will be legally responsible for discharging a function, the Secretary of State remains accountable for it, may place restrictions on onwards delegation and must publish any directions. This measure empowers appropriate, flexible local service planning by the Secretary of State to assign functions to ICBs, in the way we see them developing.
On Clause 11, I will address as a group Amendment 39, tabled by the noble Baroness, Lady Bennett, and Amendments 40, 55, 56, 69, 76, 77, 114 and 117, tabled by the noble Lord, Lord Scriven. This clause establishes a general power for the Secretary of State to direct integrated care boards in the exercise of their functions, including directing a single ICB, a group of ICBs or all ICBs. If we reflect on the 2012 Act, as I think we should, the fact is that it was overcomplicated. When it comes to practice, it has been harder to respond to challenges, not easier—which is where we want to get to. It is important that Ministers have the humility to recognise what they cannot foresee, and that it is just not possible to legislate for every situation. I believe that it is crucial to have flexibility to meet these challenges when they emerge. The Bill returns us closer to the pre-2012 situation, when—as a number of noble Lords have observed throughout the passage of this Bill—the public expected Ministers to be able to intervene, but expected them to do so sparingly, and Ministers had the necessary powers required.
Over the years, Ministers have had to respond to emerging circumstances, and the noble Lord, Lord Scriven, asked for examples. I reflect back to the fact that Ministers in 2012, for example, did not anticipate having to respond to the situation in the Mid Staffs NHS Foundation Trust, nor could they have predicted challenges to existing contracts in the NHS coming about following the invasion of Ukraine. I am sure that there are many other examples that we could look to. The noble Lord also made reference to subordinate legislation. My reading of that is that it is very much a technical term, including orders, rules, schemes and regulations authorised by this legislation. It is usual for those not to be subject to parliamentary procedure. I confirm to the noble Lord that we can commit to sharing examples of developing drafts of directions as soon as possible.
Looking forward, the power that we are looking at here will be particularly important as ICBs take on a wider set of commissioning responsibilities from NHS England. We intend to use directions more routinely to support the system; for example, in setting standards for specialised services and establishing reporting standards to measure progress—all things that noble Lords, regularly and rightly, press me to ensure are in place. The noble Baroness, Lady Coffey, gave some examples of where powers of direction could be used in addition to the point that I have already made. They are indeed ones that could be addressed by the use of the power of direction.
This clause also includes important limits on the scope of the power. I emphasise that, as a number of noble Lords have expressed concern about it. The reality is that the Secretary of State will not be able to direct ICBs to appoint specific individuals nor to direct the use of a drug, treatment or diagnostic technique that conflicts with NICE guidance or recommendations.
The noble Lord, Lord Stevens, asked about the NICE exception. The Bill reflects that NICE has not made recommendations in relation to a number of treatments and services. It is important to allow the Secretary of State to issue directions in that absence of recommendations in relation to more specialised services commissioned by ICBs.
The noble Earl, Lord Howe, asked where responsibility ultimately lies when things go wrong. As I think all sides of the House know, the ultimate responsibility is with the Secretary of State, and there is no movement on that. Ministers have to act reasonably with directions. Directions will be challengeable in courts and Ministers will ultimately be accountable to Parliament for their use. Directions will be required to be made in writing and to be published as soon as reasonably practicable.
The noble Lord, Lord Scriven, raised a question about scrutiny of some regulations. There may be a need to act quickly. In that situation, as I have said, directions will be published, and Parliament can scrutinise. The Delegated Powers and Regulatory Reform Committee, which the noble Lord referred to, has reported on the Bill and did not challenge this.
Moving to Amendment 39, I can assure the noble Baroness, Lady Bennett, that existing legislative checks and balances on local commissioning decisions will continue, such as having regard to the need to reduce health inequalities and to ensure patient choice. Directions cannot be used to undermine those duties. The intention with this power is not to micromanage the system but to be flexible and reasonable, and for it to be used for the benefit of patients and the public as new commissioning approaches develop. Despite the intention of the amendment, I fear that it works against such flexibility, which I suspect is not the intention of the noble Baroness, Lady Bennett. We do not expect to use this power to constrain ICBs when selecting providers. However, the public expect Ministers to be able to intervene if they need to protect patients and the public.