B

Baroness Merron (Lab)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 9 November 2026

Debate

Health Bill

Contribution

My noble friend has put it very clearly and I most grateful. I think the public believe that the Secretary of State has that power already, but in fact she does not, which is a point my noble friend has made on many occasions. Turning to Amendment 40, I should also draw attention to the distinction we have made between the more routinely used power of direction and the powers specifically reserved for use in cases of significant failure or risk of significant failure. Retaining the distinction between types of direction is important, as is the recognition of when an intervention is undertaken to protect patients, the public or taxpayers. I note the alternative proposal to appoint commissioners from the noble Lord, Lord Scriven, in Amendment 40. My concern is that this approach would likely be more cumbersome and would slow Ministers’ ability to intervene where significant failure was occurring—something that I know noble Lords would not want. Amendment 40 also touches on outcomes frameworks. I assure the noble Lord that I share the sentiment about the importance of outcomes frameworks, and, if necessary, we can complement existing frameworks by using directions. I will now briefly touch on Amendments 76 and 77, which relate to Clause 21. The clause transfers the requirement to conduct annual assessments of ICBs from NHS England to the Secretary of State and focuses the assessment on the statutory functions of these organisations rather than a narrow list of duties. Currently, the position is that NHS England assesses ICBs annually, using data and local insight to review their performance against their functions, including a list of duties prescribed by the current legislation. The results are published online and they inform the oversight relationship between NHS England and each ICB. However, this list of duties forms a static list of requirements which are already part of the ICBs’ statutory functions. Performance assessments need to adapt to the evolving role of ICBs as strategic commissioners, and evening out the focus across all ICB duties supports that, making assessment more flexible and meaningful as ICBs adapt. These clauses enable the Secretary of State to support the system, respond to unforeseen challenges and uphold the standards that patients expect and deserve, while ensuring that we have fairness and impartiality at the heart of the National Health Service.

More from Baroness Merron (Lab)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.