L

Lord Scriven (LD)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 9 November 2026

Debate

Health Bill

Contribution

My Lord, when we started this group, I did not expect the phrase “the Soviet model of healthcare” to be mentioned, but the noble Baroness, Lady Murphy, used it. It is always surprising what one hears and learns in Committee. From these Benches, our starting point is simple: the principle that defines the NHS is that care is free at the point of use and based on need, not ability, to pay. That is a line that I think most noble Lords would never wish us to cross. Who owns the building matters less to a patient than whether they get good care in good time, and a good outcome without paying for it. As Liberals, we start from individual patients. We ask what power the patient has, who can take it away and why. I respect what the noble Baroness, Lady Bennett, is trying to do. She is right to raise concerns about profit and public money, but her amendments are the wrong answer. They would take choice from patients, and those with the least would lose most. Let us take Herefordshire. It is a large, rural county with one NHS acute hospital: the county hospital in Hereford. The next-nearest NHS acute hospitals are in other counties, or even across the border in Wales. Many villages have few buses. The county’s own draft transport plan is still working towards better links between Hereford and market towns. Nuffield Health also has a hospital in Hereford, which provides some NHS services free at the point of use to patients. Under the noble Baroness’s presumption, that option exists only if there is no reasonable public alternative within a clinically appropriate timeframe. The test asks, “how soon?”, but not “how far?”, nor how a pensioner with no car gets to an operation in another country or county, and home again. Care is free at the point of use; the journey is not. For someone on a low income, a free operation that they cannot reach is not much use, nor is it right. A patient on a long waiting list at the only public hospital in their county should be able to choose another provider nearby, free at the point of use—whether that be private or NHS provided. Someone with money can already pay to leave the queue. Taking away that free option would not abolish the two-tier system; I believe it would deepen it. This also goes well beyond hospitals, as other noble Lords said. The new clause in the amendment after Clause 11 says a service is not publicly provided if it is contracted to a private body, and only public bodies may provide it. As noble Lords said, most GP practices are private contractors, as are many community pharmacists, high street dentists and opticians. They are the front door of the NHS. What about hospices? There are 135 independent adult hospice charities in England. The National Audit Office says the sector cared for about 251,000 people in 2023-24, with the Government funding around 29% of its income. Are those to be taken out or shut down under this amendment? As has already been pointed out, in 2023-24, over half of NHS cataract operations were done by independent providers. Bringing them back at speed into NHS public bodies would lengthen waits for older people to have their cataracts done. The term “private sector body” is not defined in the amendments, so we cannot tell which of these would fall under the presumption. The review in Amendment 36 is the most useful idea in this group from the noble Baroness, Lady Bennett, but it is framed around returning services to public provision. It should ask a neutral question: which providers—public or independent—give quality, value and fair access, with provision free at the point of use? None of this is a blank cheque for the private sector. Independent providers delivering NHS care must meet the same standards and publish the same data. They should train staff and not pick off the simple cases while the NHS keeps the complex ones. That is part of what ICB strategic commissioning needs to pick up. Independent providers delivered only around 7.5% of NHS planned care in February this year, based on their own trade body’s figures. They are a useful supplement, but they are no substitute for NHS care that is properly and publicly funded. This brings me to Clause 10. What is the point of it? What problem is it solving? Can the noble Baroness give the Committee an example of what a Secretary of State cannot do now that they could do with this clause? We need to be clear that this clause changes a provision in the 2006 Act which stops the Secretary of State from swinging between private and public. The new clause would allow to happen the very thing that the 2006 Act stopped, depending on how the Secretary of State felt when they got up that morning and decided whether they were in the mood for public or private healthcare. The Committee needs to understand what problem this is solving, because, I think like most noble Lords, I have no idea why this provision is in the Bill and what it is trying to solve. The noble Baroness, Lady Coffey, rightly asks in her amendment for us to think of patients rather than the organisation. The noble Lord, Lord Kamall, goes further, and I find his approach the most persuasive in the group. It is that, basically, a change would have to be necessary to improve patient outcomes. Surely that is the test against ideology from either a public or a private direction. The Secretary of State would also publish the reasons and lay them before Parliament. The amendments from the noble Baroness, Lady Bennett, raise serious concerns in terms of completely undermining what a public health service—the NHS—should be about. It should be about quality, about outcomes and about patients having choice. The Secretary of State should not dictate which type of hospital a patient should go to, as long as the basis is free at point of use, the quality of care is monitored, and outcomes are the same as in a publicly funded body. I really look forward to the Minister explaining the reason for Clause 10, because I believe that most noble Lords would like to understand exactly what problem it is trying to solve.

More from Lord Scriven (LD)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.