B

Baroness Merron (Lab)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 9 November 2026

Debate

Health Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I am grateful for the debate that we have just had. With permission, I will address whether Clause 10 should stand part of the Bill, look at the amendments to it and refer to those things together. As a number of noble Lords have rightly emphasised, we are indeed committed to a National Health Service that is free at the point of use. Noble Lords will be very familiar with the changes that we are making to ensure that patients are at its core, and that they find that the system works around them, rather than them having to work around the system. We see that throughout the 10-year plan. For many years, this has included the provision of NHS-commissioned services by charities and the not-for-profit and independent sectors, as referred to by the noble Baroness, Lady Murphy, the noble Lord, Lord Kamall, and my noble friends Lady Nargund and Lord Hunt, to mention a few. The fact is that all these sectors make a valuable contribution to the health of the people whom we serve. We should acknowledge that, but I think we should also celebrate it. Clause 10 prohibits the Secretary of State using their functions deliberately to shift the balance between types of providers. It strengthens and extends Section 12E of the National Health Service Act 2006 to any health service function of the Secretary of State and applies to all providers, regardless of legal form—to answer the point raised by the noble Lord, Lord Kamall. The clause does not enable privatisation or nationalisation by the front door, the back door, the side door or indeed any door that we can think about. It is a general prohibition, with one exception: where the Secretary of State considers that to act differently is in the interests of the health service. As to why we need that, currently under Section 12E, a Minister who sees a service failing and concludes that bringing it into the NHS is in the interests of the health service could not act. Equally, Ministers could not deliberately bring in charitable or independent providers to end a risky overreliance on a single NHS trust; nor could they see an entire sector dependent on a few external providers and choose to build more public capacity for the long term—something that noble Lords rightly would encourage—because such purposes are always prohibited, even though the outcomes can be beneficial. Clause 10 enables Ministers to act when the interests of the health service require it. We expect Parliament to hold Ministers to account in doing so. I say to the noble Lord, Lord Stevens, and my noble friend Lord Hunt that Ministers, in their duty to promote a comprehensive health service, have a duty to act reasonably and rationally and, as I say, to be held to account for doing so. The noble Lord, Lord Patel of Bradford—

More from Baroness Merron (Lab)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.