B

Baroness Mallalieu (Lab)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 10 November 2026

Debate

Courts and Tribunals Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I agree with every word that the noble Viscount, Lord Hailsham, uttered earlier. I, too, dislike Clause 1. Like him, if it is pushed unamended, I shall have great difficulty in supporting it later. I have to take issue with the noble Baroness who has just spoken, because there is a big difference when you are facing a trial as to which you would opt for. Which one of us would opt for the magistrates rather than a jury trial? It is a different standard of justice. I say that without in any way being insulting to magistrates, who are now fully trained—much more than they were in the days when I was still practising, about 20 years ago. They are much better equipped to deal with matters, but the reality is that a Crown Court trial usually has a senior lawyer looking at the file. They may well see the flaws, which may well change the trial’s whole course and indeed lead it to be dropped. I remember—and I do not believe it has changed in view of the number of people on the waiting list at the moment in the magistrates’ court, which is 380,000—CPS representatives doing the prosecuting coming in carrying a huge number of files of different cases, without the time to devote to looking at each one properly. That is what happens. Also, when appeals from trials in the magistrates’ court go to the Crown Court—there are not a great many of them, so it will not save a lot of time—56% succeed. Something has gone wrong. It may be that the law was not properly presented, or that there is some further evidence, or that it was just wrong on the facts, but that is an indication that things go wrong. They often go wrong because people do not have legal aid and are representing themselves. Sometimes—I say it of my own former profession—they are represented by very junior people, as is often the case in the magistrates’ court, or are not represented at all because no criminal solicitor will take the case on. I accept that there has to be a look at which cases are entitled to go to jury trial. Some minor matters clog up the courts and could be dealt with in other ways, and I know that comes into later parts of the Bill. We all want to see a solution to this dreadful waiting time which means that people are waiting in custody for a considerable time or are waiting to give evidence in trials. That has to be tackled, but I cannot see the provisions in Clause 1 having the desired effect of reducing them. If any one of us would choose a jury trial, so would, I suspect, the majority of defendants. To take away a right of appeal about allocation seems a denial of justice. I do not believe that that is something that my Government, the Government who in 1945 brought in the legal aid system, want to see. I hope the Minister will look again at this, because, frankly, it is not right and it is not going to do the job. There are other ways that have been mentioned already, and there are probably a great deal more that we can come up with which will help to cut that dreadful backlog.

More from Baroness Mallalieu (Lab)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.